What is the law when a same-sex couple, one of whom is an Israeli citizen and the other a national of a foreign country, who live together as common-law partners, seek to regularize their status in Israel?
How can this be done? Which laws and procedures govern status regularization in such cases? And in general, how should one deal with the Ministry of the Interior in applications of this kind? We discuss all this in the article below.
What Is the Law on Entering and Staying in Israel?
Entry into Israel is not a right granted to everyone, but only to citizens of the State of Israel, and the same applies to staying in Israel. The rule on entering and staying in Israel is set out in the Entry into Israel Law, 5712-1952 (the “Entry into Israel Law”).
Section 1 of this Law provides that a person who is not an Israeli citizen may enter the country either under an oleh visa or under a visa granted under the Entry into Israel Law.
In addition, the Entry into Israel Law gives the Minister of the Interior the authority to grant a residence visa or to deny a visa to a particular person. For example, Section 2 of the Entry into Israel Law provides that the Minister may grant a permit for transit residence (usually up to five days), a visitor visa (usually limited to three months), a temporary residence visa (usually up to three years), and a permanent residence visa in Israel.
In addition, as noted, the Minister of the Interior also has the authority to revoke a residence visa, to order the deportation from Israel of a person who has breached the conditions of his or her residence visa, and to set certain conditions for obtaining a residence visa.
The Entry into Israel Law is one of the core laws in the field of immigration in Israel; it can be said to be one side of a coin known, as noted, as “the immigration law of the State of Israel.” The other side of the coin is the Citizenship Law, 5712-1952 (the “Citizenship Law”), whose purpose and content are explained below.
Ways of Obtaining Citizenship in Israel:
The second important law in the field of immigration in Israel is the Citizenship Law. This law deals with how Israeli citizenship is obtained, and like the Entry into Israel Law, it gives the Minister of the Interior substantive authority in the matters it regulates.
Among other things, the Citizenship Law sets out various ways to obtain Israeli citizenship. One way is through aliyah. Aliyah is a right reserved for Jews under the Law of Return, 5710-1950.
Another way is through naturalization in Israel, under Section 5 of the Citizenship Law. That is, a person who has lived in Israel for several years, speaks Hebrew, has stayed in Israel lawfully during those years, and has settled in Israel with the intention of living and working there and making it the center of his or her life, may receive citizenship under the provisions of the Citizenship Law, subject to many conditions that we do not discuss in detail in this article.
Israeli citizenship can also be granted by birth, by adoption, and by grant, that is, when the Minister of the Interior decides to grant citizenship to a person who has made a significant contribution to the State of Israel.
However, the option closest and most relevant to the subject of this article is the possibility of obtaining citizenship under Section 7 of the Citizenship Law. This option concerns the naturalization of a husband and wife, that is, where one spouse is an Israeli citizen and the other is a national of a foreign country. Section 7 provides:
“Spouses of whom one is an Israeli national or has applied for naturalization and meets or has been exempted from the requirements of section 5(a) may obtain Israeli nationality by naturalization even if they do not meet the requirements of section 5(a).”
On the purpose of Section 7 of the Citizenship Law, the words of the Appeals Tribunal are apt:
“Section 7 of the Citizenship Law is intended to make the naturalization process easier where the person is the spouse of an Israeli citizen. However, this does not simply mean that the respondent must grant citizenship to anyone who asks, merely because he is the spouse of an Israeli citizen.
[…] There is no doubt, and this has been held more than once, that the respondent’s discretion in granting status is extremely broad.”[1]This provision concerns marriage, and husband and wife. Our article deals with couples who are “common-law partners,” and in particular with same-sex couples living together as common-law partners.
However, in the case of a husband and wife, as long as they are married (even if they married in a civil marriage performed in another country), they have the right to regularize their status in Israel.
Status regularization is carried out under the provisions of a procedure called the “Procedure for Handling the Grant of Status to a Foreign Spouse Married to an Israeli Citizen” (the “Marriage Procedure”).
Under that procedure, the couple must submit an application to the Ministry of the Interior, undergo an interview, and prove the validity and genuineness of their marriage, and after passing a preliminary stage (in which, as noted, the genuineness of the marriage and the absence of a security bar are examined), they move on to a process called the “graduated procedure.”
This process will also be relevant later, when we look more closely at regularizing status for common-law partners and same-sex couples.
At this point we will only note that during the graduated procedure, the spouse who is not an Israeli citizen receives a temporary residence visa in Israel, which is renewed every year.
At the end of each year, the genuineness and nature of the couple’s relationship are examined again through an interview at the Ministry of the Interior. In the absence of any bar, and in the absence of a suspicion that the marriage is fictitious, the foreign spouse is granted citizenship at the end of the process. The Supreme Court describes the graduated procedure as follows:
“The graduated procedure for naturalization by virtue of marriage is divided into stages in which the foreign spouse who meets the required criteria is granted status in Israel: first, he or she is given a B/1 visitor residence permit for six months (under Regulation 5 of the Entry into Israel Regulations, 5734-1974) (the Entry into Israel Regulations); then an A/5 temporary residence permit, renewable annually for a period of up to four years (under Regulation 6(e) of the Entry into Israel Regulations); and finally, where the procedure is completed successfully, he or she is granted citizenship.”[2]
If the graduated procedure is stopped because of failures or certain suspicions, the couple can appeal the Ministry of the Interior’s decisions to the Appeals Tribunal.
Regularizing Status for Common-Law Partners and Same-Sex Couples:
The Citizenship Law provides for naturalization in the case of lawfully married couples. But the question arises: what answer is there for couples living together as common-law partners, and particularly for same-sex couples?
The answer lies in a procedure called the “Procedure for Handling the Grant of Status to Partners of Israelis, Including Same-Sex Partners” (the “Common-Law Partners Procedure”). This procedure was issued not under Section 7 of the Citizenship Law mentioned above, but under the Entry into Israel Law, by virtue of the Minister of the Interior’s authority to decide who will be entitled to enter and stay in Israel and who will not.
But before discussing the procedure itself, we explain who common-law partners are and what the law is regarding same-sex couples, as follows:
Common-law partners are couples who, by their conduct and by their own choice, have in effect bound their fates together. In practice, there is no substantive difference between a married couple and a couple living together as common-law partners.
These are couples who live together, run a shared household, and have a stable, ordinary relationship, the only difference between them and a formally married couple being the existence of a “marriage certificate.” The definition of common-law partners can be summarized as follows:
“The institution of common-law partnership allows those in a marriage-like relationship to enjoy most of the civil legal consequences of the institution of marriage, including almost all the economic rights and obligations of married couples.
In this way, the institution of common-law partnership provides some answer to the plight of those who are barred from marrying and of those who ideologically oppose the religious marriage ceremony and the content of religious marriage law.
This aspect of the law of common-law partners is connected to a broader trend of fostering substitutes for civil marriage, such as consular marriages, civil marriages outside Israel, and, in certain cases, even private marriages.”[3]
As for same-sex couples, a few principles in Israel need to be explained. In Israel, marriage and divorce can be performed only according to the religious personal law that applies to the couple.
That is, only a man and a woman of the same religion can marry, and even when they marry, they are subject to the provisions of religious law. Correspondingly, Israeli couples in which each partner belongs to a different religion cannot marry in Israel, because no recognized religion recognizes the validity of marriages between members of different religions.
This applies all the more to same-sex couples: neither the Jewish, nor the Muslim, nor the Christian religion recognizes same-sex relationships; quite the opposite.
Therefore, in Israel, same-sex couples can of course live as common-law partners in every respect, but they cannot marry in Israel. However, it is possible to marry in a foreign country and then register in Israel as married.
This right is certainly available to opposite-sex couples, and it is also available to same-sex couples, provided that the country in which they married recognizes the validity of the marriage.
To date, the case law of the Israeli Supreme Court has not expressly recognized the substantive validity of marriages between same-sex couples, but it has allowed same-sex couples to be registered in Israel as married by the Ministry of the Interior’s registration officer. The Supreme Court explained this in the Ben-Ari case:
“Before concluding, we emphasize again what we decide today and what we do not decide today. We hold that, within the statistical-registrational status of the Population Register, and against the background of the registration officer’s role as a collector of statistical material for the purpose of maintaining the Register, the registration officer must register in the Population Register what emerges from the public certificate submitted to him by the petitioners, namely that the petitioners are married.
We do not hold that marriages between persons of the same sex are recognized in Israel; we do not recognize a new status of such marriages; we take no position on the recognition in Israel of marriages between persons of the same sex performed outside Israel (whether between residents of Israel or between those who are not residents of Israel).
The answer to these questions, which we do not decide today, is difficult and complex […] It is to be hoped that the Knesset will be able to address them, or some of them.”[4]
This brings us back to the question we started with: how can same-sex couples regularize their status?
The answer is under the Common-Law Partners Procedure mentioned above. As with the Marriage Procedure, under the Common-Law Partners Procedure the couple must also prove the genuineness of their relationship when applying to regularize status.
In general, we note that for common-law partners the burden of proving the genuineness of the relationship is even heavier than the burden on married couples.
When the application is submitted to the Ministry of the Interior, the couple will be summoned to a first interview, in which they will be asked to present a wide range of evidence and documents showing the genuineness of the relationship.
After that, a security check is usually carried out to examine whether there is any bar to allowing the foreign partner to stay in Israel. That is, at the first stage the couple must prove the genuineness of the relationship, the absence of any security bar, and that their center of life is in Israel and will remain there.
All these conditions are prerequisites for moving on to the graduated procedure mentioned above, which also applies to married couples regularizing their status.
When a couple moves on to the graduated procedure, the partner who is not an Israeli citizen receives a residence visa for one year, which is renewed every year, usually for 3 to 4 years, and at the end of the process the partner may receive a temporary resident visa.
We recall that every year during the graduated procedure, the nature and genuineness of the couple’s relationship are examined again, all in order to prevent abuse of the relationship and to prevent fictitious relationships.
If the graduated procedure is successful, the partner who is not an Israeli resident will receive permanent residency, but, as noted, this is a process that lasts several years.
The Position of the Case Law:
Over the years, many judgments have been given on regularizing the status of same-sex couples who are common-law partners, both by the District Courts and the Supreme Court and by the Appeals Tribunals established under the Entry into Israel Law, which also adjudicate matters under the Common-Law Partners Procedure. Let us review some of them:
In a case in which a same-sex couple who were common-law partners petitioned against the Minister of the Interior’s decision to remove one of them from Israel, the couple argued that, because they were common-law partners, there was no reason or justification to submit an advance application for status regularization (while the foreign partner was in his country of origin); rather, he should be allowed to come to Israel and then submit the application.
The Appeals Tribunal dismissed the appeal and chose not to interfere with the discretion of the Ministry of the Interior official in the circumstances:
“It cannot be inferred from the absence of an appropriate provision in the Common-Law Partners Procedure that the common-law partners of Israelis are permitted to come to Israel for the purpose of settling without submitting an application.
It should be borne in mind that we are not dealing with provisions of a law or regulations, but with administrative instructions intended to guide the discretion of the respondent’s officials when applications are submitted to it on various matters within its authority […] ‘Even where a procedure exists, this does not mean that there is no longer any need to exercise discretion and examine the case in its individual circumstances.’
[…] Therefore, even if I assume that the Common-Law Partners Procedure should have included a provision regulating the submission of advance applications to come to Israel, it is clear that the absence of such a provision does not indicate any negative arrangement, but merely leaves the matter to the discretion of the official handling it.”[5]In another case, the Appeals Tribunal rejected the argument of a (same-sex) couple that they were entitled to naturalization under the Citizenship Law because they had married in a foreign country. Applying Supreme Court case law, the Appeals Tribunal held that the marriage is not recognized in substance:
“It follows that there is no reason to apply the naturalization procedure to the appellants, and appellant 2 is not entitled to naturalize under Section 7 of the Citizenship Law. It should be clarified that appellant 2 will be entitled, when he becomes eligible for permanent resident status, to naturalize under Section 5 of the Citizenship Law (which is not within the jurisdiction of this Tribunal).
As long as the appellants’ marriage is not recognized in Israel, there is no basis for their argument that they are discriminated against compared with couples whose marriages are recognized in Israel. In principle, the appeal is dismissed.”[6]
In Summary:
Regularizing status in Israel in general, and especially for common-law partners, including same-sex couples, is a complex and complicated subject that requires knowledge and experience of the bureaucratic maze of the Ministry of the Interior and the courts.
Status is regularized under the Common-Law Partners Procedure, which sets out a long process. It should be noted, however, that even if you have cleared the initial hurdles, the graduated procedure is a long process during which unexpected events may occur, which always call for the guidance of a status regularization lawyer who is skilled and experienced in immigration.
[1] Appeal (Jerusalem) 1674-14 Artyom Baron v. Ministry of the Interior (published in Nevo), para. 15.
[2] AAA 9102/12 Tatiana Kuzmina v. Ministry of the Interior – Population, Immigration and Border Crossings Authority (published in Nevo).
[3] Shahar Lifshitz, Cohabitants in Light of the Civil Theory of Family Law [Hebrew] (Nevo Publishing, 2005), p. 65.
[4] HCJ 3045/05 Yossi Ben-Ari v. Director of the Population Administration (published in Nevo).
[5] Appeal (Tel Aviv) 2408-15 Dan Stoleru et al. v. Ministry of the Interior (published in Nevo), para. 15.
[6] Appeal (Jerusalem) 2316-15 Gilboa et al. v. Ministry of the Interior (published in Nevo), para. 9.
