In recent years there has been significant immigration to Israel, both from African countries and from the countries of the former Soviet Union. A large part of this immigration consists of people who claim that they are persecuted in their own countries, and therefore, on arriving in Israel, they apply for “refugee” status on the grounds of persecution in their country of origin. In the article below, we discuss how it is possible, and advisable, to obtain refugee status in Israel, as follows:
The Convention Relating to the Status of “Refugees”:
In 1951 an international convention called the “Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees” (the “Convention”) was signed. The State of Israel, whose citizens had known the slaughter and atrocities of the Holocaust, was even among the initiators of this Convention, and signed it.
The Convention sets out the treatment that the signatory states must give to refugees persecuted in their countries of origin, and it also defines who “refugees” are. In addition, the Convention imposes a number of prohibitions on the signatory states regarding the treatment of refugees, as we explain below.
It should also be noted at this point that Israel has indeed signed the Convention, but has never incorporated it into domestic legislation in the Knesset. Nevertheless, it should be noted that Israel has declared, and still declares, that it acts in accordance with the provisions of the Convention and is committed to it.
The Convention provides that a “refugee” is a person who is in a foreign country that is not his or her home country, owing to a fear of persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, or membership of a particular group, including an ethnic group or a group with ideological characteristics.
A refugee is also a person who is outside his or her home country and cannot return to it for fear of harm in the circumstances described above.
The Convention imposes a number of obligations on the member states, as follows: an obligation to allow access to the courts, meaning that people who come to Israel and claim to be entitled to refugee status may apply to the courts of the country.
An obligation to treat refugees equally, meaning that a state party to the Convention must treat refugees fairly and equally, without distinguishing between refugees from one country and refugees from another.
The Convention also imposes an obligation to allow refugees to practice their religion freely and not to infringe that freedom. The Convention imposes an obligation to provide relief and employment: the member states must also grant refugees social rights, including the right to work, although in certain cases these rights are subject to the laws of the state.
Another obligation, and a most fundamental one, imposed on the member states is the obligation not to return asylum seekers to their countries of origin.
Another basic principle of the Convention is that an asylum seeker will enjoy “refugee” status in the first country he or she reaches, that is: the right to receive status does not necessarily exist where the refugee has passed through several countries after leaving the country of origin.
This rule was added in 1988 in a binding decision of the UN High Commissioner for Refugees. Still, even where a refugee left the country of origin and passed through several countries before applying for refugee status, he or she cannot automatically be returned to the country of origin unless several conditions are met. This is how the Appeals Tribunal described it in an appeal filed by an asylum seeker (which we discuss further below):
“The first condition is that the refugee or asylum seeker be protected from return to his country of origin, and the second condition is that the refugee or asylum seeker is expected to receive basic humane treatment until a solution is found for him, which may be provided in cooperation with the High Commissioner.”[1]
The Law on Entry into Israel:
Before we discuss how the status of refugees and asylum seekers in Israel is regularized, we explain below the law on entry and status regularization in Israel. The Entry into Israel Law, 5712-1952 (the “Entry into Israel Law”) provides that entry into the country shall be under a residence visa, and the authority in this matter is vested in the Minister of the Interior.
Moreover, the Minister of the Interior has the authority to extend a residence visa, to cancel a residence visa, and even to require a guarantee to be deposited as a condition for granting a residence visa.
The Entry into Israel Law also provides that entry into the country shall be through a border station, such as an airport, a seaport, or a land border crossing. Entering Israel unlawfully, or infiltrating the country’s territory other than through a lawful border crossing, is a criminal offense.
As for residence visas, the Entry into Israel Law provides for several types of visas: a transit visa limited to a few days; a visitor visa (B/1), which gives its holder the right to work; a visitor visa (B/2), which gives its holder the right to visit Israel, in most cases for three months.
There are also visas for temporary residence in Israel, marked with the letter “A,” for example the A/1 visa, granted to people who wish, and are entitled, to immigrate to Israel, the A/2 visa, granted to people who come to study in Israel, and others.
It follows that the starting point is that entry into Israel must take place through an official border crossing, and with a valid visa granted by the Minister of the Interior, who is authorized to restrict it, cancel it, and also order deportation.
The Situation of Asylum Seekers in Israel:
Today there are a great many asylum seekers in Israel, numbering in the tens of thousands, from African countries. In addition, in the past year there has also been an increase in asylum seekers from the countries of the former Soviet Union (mainly Ukraine and Georgia).
The main claims of asylum seekers from Africa (usually from Eritrea and Sudan) are political persecution, unwillingness to serve in the army, and the persecution and severe punishments imposed on those who refuse military service in Eritrea.
As for asylum seekers from Ukraine, many claim persecution because of the recent fighting between Ukraine and Russia over the Crimean Peninsula.
As for the number of applicants, the words of the Appeals Tribunal, which reviewed the statistics on the subject, are apt:
“As of 10.5.16, 7,041 asylum applications had been filed by Eritreans; according to the same data, in 2015 alone 7,534 applications for political asylum were filed with the respondent, of which slightly fewer than half (3,596) were filed by citizens of Eritrea and the rest, 3,958, by citizens of other countries (of whom 1,373 were citizens of Sudan, 734 citizens of Georgia, and 702 citizens of Ukraine). That is, about half of the asylum applications by citizens of Eritrea were filed in 2015 alone.”[2]
Accordingly, in recent years there has also been a public controversy, mainly regarding migrants from Africa. Some argue that they are indeed persecuted, while others argue that they are seeking a livelihood and are not people fleeing their country of origin because of persecution.
At the time of writing, it must be said frankly that a considerable part of the applications for refugee status, especially those of asylum seekers from Africa, have not yet been heard and decided; a small number have been decided in favor of the applicants and a small number against them. We refer to the case law on this below.
The Procedure for Obtaining “Refugee” Status:
As in any country, a person who wishes to obtain refugee status must apply for it on arriving in the destination country, that is, the country to which he or she fled from the country of origin.
In Israel, the status of asylum seekers is mainly governed by a Ministry of the Interior procedure called the “Procedure for Handling Political Asylum Seekers in Israel (2011)” (the “Procedure”).
The purpose of the Procedure is to regulate and set out how applications by asylum seekers are handled, in accordance with the provisions of the Convention. Moreover, the Procedure also provides that an asylum seeker will not be removed from Israel until a decision is made on his or her application.
Under the Procedure, the process of obtaining refugee status consists of several stages, as follows:
Submitting the application: Under the Procedure, a person who wishes to obtain refugee status in Israel must submit a formal application, either at a border crossing or at the offices of the Ministry of the Interior, within one year of the day he or she entered Israel.
Such an application may also be submitted where a person who entered the country has been placed in custody. The Procedure provides that where a person has been in Israel for more than a year and applies for political asylum, the application will be rejected immediately.
Registration and identification: After the application is submitted, the asylum seeker is registered, which includes taking identifying details, such as fingerprints, DNA, and a photograph, as well as other details such as contact information.
Initial interview: When identification and registration are completed, the asylum seeker undergoes a basic interview. This is a relatively short interview in which general questions are asked in order to examine whether there is indeed reason to believe that the person is an asylum seeker.
The interview is conducted in the asylum seeker’s official language (including through an interpreter), and the asylum seeker may be represented at the interview by an immigration lawyer, but the lawyer will not be allowed to answer in the applicant’s place.
Comprehensive interview: After the basic interview, the Ministry of the Interior official may decide to reject the asylum seeker’s application. Even if the application is rejected, however, the applicant will be given time to file an appeal against the decision, and will not yet be deported from Israel.
On the other hand, if the basic interview is successful, the asylum seeker will later be summoned to a more comprehensive interview, which also lasts longer and includes a much wider range of questions.
Consideration by the committee: At the end of the comprehensive interview, the Population Authority official will decide whether to refer the asylum seeker’s case to an advisory committee or to the committee chair.
Where there is a suspicion that there is no reason to grant political asylum to the applicant, the application will be referred for decision to the committee chair, who, after reviewing the material and the asylum seeker’s details, will pass his or her conclusions to the Director General of the Population and Immigration Authority, who will make the final decision on the application.
Alternatively, the decision may be referred to the Advisory Committee on Refugees, which will also pass its conclusions to the Minister of the Interior. If the Minister decides to grant political asylum, the asylum seeker will be given an A/5 permit to stay in Israel, that is, a temporary resident visa, which gives the asylum seeker the right to National Insurance and health insurance.
A few more remarks should now be made regarding the status of refugees: Today, because of the workload of the Population and Immigration Authority, a long time passes between the basic interview, and indeed between the submission of the application, and the comprehensive interview, so the asylum seeker must apply to the Population Authority from time to time to extend his or her residence visa in Israel.
In addition, where an application for political asylum has been approved, the Procedure provides that a separate application must be submitted for the refugee’s family members, which is considered by the advisory committee.
The committee will examine the genuineness of the marriage and of the relationship between the spouses, as well as whether other immigration options exist in their case (the case of the children or the spouse).
It should also be noted that asylum seeker status will not be granted to nationals of enemy states, such as Syria, Iran, and others. However, even in such cases, the possibility of granting asylum is subject to security considerations and to the possibilities of immigrating to other countries.
The Position of the Case Law:
One of the most important rulings given in Israel recently, and on the recognition of asylum seekers generally, is the case of Mesgana Abraham, who fled Eritrea because he did not want to serve in the army.
He left his guard post, crossed the border into Ethiopia, and later reached Israel. The Ministry of the Interior rejected his application for status, relying on an opinion that held that desertion from the Eritrean army does not give rise to a fear of persecution within the meaning of the Convention.
The Appeals Tribunal rejected the Population and Immigration Authority’s position and ordered that his case be re-examined. It held that each case must be examined on its merits, but that asylum applications cannot be rejected automatically solely because they involve desertion from the Eritrean army:
“The appeal must be allowed: the respondent’s decision to reject the appellant’s application for political asylum cannot stand, because the opinion on which it relies empties of content the State’s undertaking to act in accordance with the Refugee Convention, in its categorical determination that desertion or evasion of military service in Eritrea does not in itself amount to political persecution and that, therefore, an asylum seeker from Eritrea whose only claim for asylum in Israel is that he deserted or evaded military service will not be recognized as a refugee.”[3]
On the other hand, the Appeals Tribunal recently dismissed the appeal of an asylum seeker from Eritrea who had left the country for Cuba, stayed there for a period, and came to Israel.
The asylum seeker in that case argued that he should be granted refugee status because there is no “democracy” in Eritrea and the economy is in a very difficult state that does not allow its residents to earn a living. As noted, the Tribunal rejected the application and even held that the appellant had acted in bad faith:
“The appellant left Israel using an Eritrean passport, received ‘refugee’ status in Cuba, and apparently sought to reach ‘better’ countries than Cuba (the United States, Germany) and, in the end, when he did not succeed, returned to Israel. In the special circumstances of this appellant, based on the information gathered about him, I hold that he acted in bad faith and that his case does not fall within the criteria set out in the Refugee Convention.”[4]
In another case, an asylum application was filed by a Nigerian citizen who claimed that he had taken part in fighting against the government as part of a rebel movement. The asylum seeker left the movement and sought to mend his ways, but still feared the government.
He came to Israel and applied for refugee status; his application was rejected because a “well-founded fear of persecution” had not been proven, and certainly not a fear of persecution meeting the standards required by the Convention. An appeal was filed against the decision, and it too was dismissed, on the following grounds:
“The asylum ground raised by the appellant, of persecution by the government because of political opinion, must be rejected because, even if proven, it does not confer protection under any of the grounds listed in the Convention, and because a well-founded fear of personal persecution was not proven.
The asylum ground raised by the appellant because of his membership in the MEND movement and his withdrawal from it must be rejected, since no well-founded fear of personal persecution was found, nor was it proven that the appellant cannot avail himself of the protection of the state authorities or relocate.”[5]
In Summary:
Regularizing the status of refugees is a very complex matter, and even today there is still no adequate response to the many applications submitted to the State of Israel. There is no doubt that some applications are justified, but on the other hand some applications may be an abuse by people who wish to remain in Israel for economic reasons.
Nevertheless, we believe that obtaining refugee status in Israel is a complex and complicated matter that requires proper legal representation by a Ministry of the Interior lawyer with experience in assisting asylum seekers.
[1] Appeal (Jerusalem) 1010-14 Mesgana Abraham v. Ministry of the Interior – Population Authority (published in Nevo), para. 74.
[2] Ibid., para. 5.
[3] Ibid., para. 167.
[4] Appeal (Jerusalem) 2576-16 Germai Ahlati v. Ministry of the Interior – Population Authority (published in Nevo), para. 136.
[5] Appeal (Jerusalem) 2228-14 Ado Oguma v. Population Authority (published in Nevo), para. 28.
