Understanding the Term “Person Staying in Israel Unlawfully” (Shabach)
Employing persons who are staying in Israel unlawfully carries significant legal, financial, and security risks.
Understanding the term “person staying in Israel unlawfully,” known in official Hebrew terminology as a shabach (plural: shabachim), and the legal framework governing the entry and stay of foreign nationals in Israel is fundamental for any employer or anyone who has dealings with them.
The Definition of a Shabach Under Israeli Law
A person staying unlawfully (shabach) is a person who is within the territory of the State of Israel without a valid permit to stay. This definition is broad and includes several categories: foreign nationals who entered the country unlawfully, those who entered in an orderly manner but did not leave at the end of the fixed period approved for them, and those who have breached the conditions of the permit granted to them to stay in the country.
The term “foreign national” refers to a resident or citizen of a foreign country, while “infiltrators” are foreigners who entered Israel unlawfully and not through official border crossings.
Although the term “shabach” can refer to a citizen of any country, in common usage it refers mainly to Palestinians who are residents of Judea and Samaria and the Gaza Strip.
For this group, specific entry permits (known as a “tasrih”) are required. They are issued by the Coordination and Liaison Administration and specify the areas that may be entered and the purposes of the stay (such as employment, medical needs, or personal needs).
Permits to Enter and Stay in Israel (Entry into Israel Law, 5712-1952)
The Entry into Israel Law, 5712-1952, is the main legal framework governing the entry and stay of persons who are not Israeli citizens. Section 1 of the Law provides that the entry of a person who is not an Israeli citizen shall be under an oleh visa or a visa under this Law, and his or her stay shall be under a residence permit.
The Minister of the Interior has broad authority to grant various types of residence permits, including: a visa and permit for transit residence (up to five days, extendable up to ten days), a visa and permit for visitor residence (up to three months, extendable up to two years), a visa and permit for temporary residence (up to three years, extendable up to two years), and a visa and permit for permanent residence.
The Law makes clear that a person who is not an Israeli citizen or an oleh and is in Israel without a residence permit shall be removed from Israel as soon as possible and may be held in custody until removal. The Minister of the Interior may also set conditions for granting a visa or residence permit, including a requirement for a cash deposit or other guarantee.
The distinction between a general entry permit and a specific work permit is critical.
Employing a foreign worker who does not hold a valid work permit is an offense, even if he or she holds a general permit to stay (for example, for medical purposes).
This means that employers cannot rely on the mere presence of a foreign worker in the country; they must carefully verify the type of permit and its validity, and make sure that it expressly allows employment in Israel.
This places an active and significant burden of checking and verification on the employer and turns what seems to be a bureaucratic detail into a material legal risk.
The Legal Framework Prohibiting the Employment of Shabachim
Entry into Israel Law, 5712-1952
The Entry into Israel Law strictly prohibits employing a person who is staying in Israel unlawfully. Section 12A of this Law provides that employing, lodging, and transporting residents of Judea, Samaria, and the Gaza Strip who are staying in Israel unlawfully are criminal offenses punishable by two years’ imprisonment or a fine.
- Unlawful lodging: A person who, for payment or without payment, makes a place to sleep available to a foreign resident who entered Israel unlawfully or is staying there unlawfully, or helps him or her obtain a place to sleep, is liable to two years’ imprisonment or a fine.
- Unlawful employment: An employer who employed a worker who is a resident of the Area and is not permitted to work in Israel under this Law is liable to two years’ imprisonment or a fine.
- Unlawful transport: An employer or manpower agent who transports by vehicle a foreign resident staying in Israel unlawfully is liable to two years’ imprisonment or a fine.
The Law places the burden of proof on the person who committed the act (employment, lodging, or transport) to prove that he or she checked that the resident of the Area had documents showing that he or she had entered and was staying lawfully, or that, in the circumstances, he or she should not have known that the resident was acting unlawfully.
Foreign Workers (Prohibition of Unlawful Employment and Assurance of Fair Conditions) Law, 5751-1991
The Foreign Workers Law comprehensively regulates the terms of employment of foreign workers in Israel, including the process of obtaining an employment permit and the employer’s obligations toward the worker and the State.
Section 2: Unlawful employment:
- Section 2(a)(1): An employer who employed a foreign worker who is not permitted to work in Israel under the Entry into Israel Law is liable to double the fine set in Section 61(a)(2) of the Penal Law, and to an additional fine of four times the fine set in Section 61(c) of the Penal Law for each day on which the offense continues.
- Section 2(a)(2): Concerns employing a foreign worker in breach of Section 1M (permit to employ a foreign worker), and the penalty is the same as under Section 2(a)(1).
- Section 2(b): Lists additional offenses related to unlawful employment, such as failure to obtain a medical certificate, lack of a written employment contract, lack of medical insurance, failure to provide suitable housing, failure to keep required documents, failure to submit a report to the Commissioner, failure to provide a pay slip or providing an incomplete pay slip, failure to make a deposit, and unlawful deductions from wages. The penalties for these offenses range from double the fine to four times the fine set in the Penal Law, plus a daily fine for each day the offense continues. If the offense was committed in the course of business, it may also be punishable by one year’s imprisonment.
Section 2A: Unlawful lodging:
- Prohibits an employer or manpower agent from knowingly making a place to sleep available to a foreign worker who entered Israel unlawfully, or who is staying there unlawfully, or who is working in Israel without a lawful work permit. The penalty is double the fine set in Section 61(a)(2) of the Penal Law, and if the offense was committed in the course of his or her occupation, a fine or six months’ imprisonment. The burden of proof is on the employer or agent to prove that he or she checked the documents or should not have known.
Section 3: Unlawful placement:
- A manpower agent who placed for work a foreign worker whose employment is an offense under Section 2 is liable to double the fine set in Section 61(a)(2) of the Penal Law, or six months’ imprisonment.
Section 4: Penalties – de facto employer:
- A de facto employer with whom a foreign worker who is not permitted to work in Israel is employed is liable to the same penalty as an employer who committed an offense under Section 2(a)(1).
- Breach of an obligation toward a foreign worker employed by him or her (for example, medical insurance or suitable housing): six months’ imprisonment or double the fine set in Section 61(a)(2) of the Penal Law, plus a daily fine.
Section 5: Liability of an officer:
- An officer must supervise and do everything possible to prevent offenses under Sections 2 to 4 by the corporation or its employees. An officer who breaches this duty is liable to double the fine set in Section 61(a)(2) of the Penal Law. There is a presumption that if an offense was committed by a corporation, an officer breached his or her duty, unless he or she proves that he or she acted without criminal intent and without negligence and did everything possible to prevent the offense.
Legislative Amendments and Recent Updates
Israeli legislation on the employment of persons staying unlawfully has been marked by continued tightening. The Unlawful Stay (Prohibition of Assistance) Law of 1996, which began as a temporary provision, became a permanent arrangement in 2012, with certain exemptions for individual drivers and taxi drivers.
This trend intensified in 2024 with amendments to the Entry into Israel Law that doubled the penalty for employers in aggravating circumstances (up to 7 years’ imprisonment), and with further bills that emphasized the link between these offenses and terrorist activity.
The trend that grew stronger after the 2024 amendments did not stop, and during 2025 further legislative initiatives were advanced in the Knesset that expressly link the entry of shabachim into Israel to security considerations and propose to toughen the penalties and the accompanying consequences even further.
The State sees the offenses of employing, lodging, and transporting shabachim not only as a breach of labor law but as a security threat, particularly with regard to residents of Judea and Samaria. Parallel provisions in the Entry into Israel Law and the Foreign Workers Law create duplication, but they also underline how seriously the State treats the issue.
Employers are required to prove that they took all reasonable measures to verify that the worker is lawfully present, and a claim of lack of knowledge is not enough. Documentation and significant due diligence are required, because the legal risk today is much more serious than in the past.
Consequences and Sanctions for Employing Shabachim
Employing persons staying in Israel unlawfully may lead to a wide range of sanctions, from serious criminal liability, through administrative orders, to far-reaching civil and financial consequences.
Indictments and Criminal Liability
The Israeli authorities do not hesitate to file indictments, including serious ones, for these offenses.
Employing, lodging, or transporting a shabach is a serious criminal offense. In the Khatib ruling, the Supreme Court held that the appropriate penalty for these offenses should be a significant term of actual imprisonment, and that only in highly exceptional circumstances will the court consider replacing imprisonment with community service.
While an empirical study from 2009 showed that the Magistrates’ Courts did not always apply this ruling and imposed lighter sentences, in recent years, particularly in light of the security situation, sentencing policy has become considerably harsher. For example, people who transported suicide bombers were sentenced to actual prison terms ranging from 9 to 30 years.
The Israel Police also take a tough line, arresting employers of shabachim and applying to have them held in custody until the end of the proceedings.
The Law also sets out aggravating circumstances that double the penalty. If the offense was committed in these circumstances, the penalty can reach four years’ imprisonment or double the fine.
Aggravating circumstances include: lodging or employing two or more foreign residents; lodging or employing a foreign resident for two or more consecutive days; or lodging a foreign resident in order to employ him or her.
A 2024 amendment to the Entry into Israel Law further increased the penalty for an employer in aggravating circumstances (more than two days) and set a penalty of up to 7 years’ imprisonment.
In transport cases, aggravating circumstances include transporting three or more shabachim (who are not family members), transport as part of organized transport services, or modifying a vehicle in order to conceal a shabach.
In addition to prison sentences, heavy fines are imposed:
Administrative fines: Amounts ranging from NIS 5,000 to NIS 10,000 for each worker employed unlawfully, and an additional fine for each other violation of the law. For a repeat offense, the fines are doubled.
Criminal fines:
- Employing a foreign resident who is not permitted to work in Israel: two years’ imprisonment or the fine set in Section 61(a)(3) of the Penal Law, amounting to NIS 67,300.
- Breach of provisions relating to an employment contract, medical insurance, suitable housing, or deductions from wages beyond what is permitted: one year’s imprisonment or a fine of NIS 104,400 (if the offense was not committed in the course of business, the fine alone).
- Unlawful placement of a foreign worker: a fine of up to NIS 52,200.
- The maximum fine for employment or lodging can reach one hundred thousand shekels.
- In aggravating circumstances, a fine of no less than NIS 10,000 for an individual and, for a corporation, no less than NIS 40,000, unless the court decides otherwise for special reasons.
Current fine amounts under Section 61 of the Penal Law:
- Section 61(a)(2) (imprisonment of more than 6 months and not more than one year): a fine of up to NIS 26,100.
- Section 61(a)(3) (imprisonment of more than one year and not more than three years): a fine of up to NIS 67,300.
- Section 61(a)(4) (imprisonment of more than three years): a fine of up to NIS 202,000.
- Section 61(c) (continuing offense): an additional fine of up to NIS 1,300 per day.
Administrative Liability
Beyond criminal liability, employers are also exposed to serious administrative sanctions. Employing a shabach may lead to a closure order against the business for up to 30 days.
There are two types of closure orders: a judicial closure order, issued by the court (after conviction or before conviction), and an administrative closure order, issued by administrative bodies such as the police, the Ministry of Labor, or the local authority, for a period of 30 days, which the court can extend. Recently, the police have closed hundreds of construction sites and businesses where shabachim were caught.
The considerations in issuing a closure order include the degree of danger or harm to the public, previous offenses committed at the site, the owner’s or occupier’s knowledge that the offenses were being committed, how essential the site is to the public, and the extent of the harm that would be caused to the employer.
Enforcement powers are exercised by various bodies. The Population and Immigration Authority enforces the law prohibiting the employment of foreign workers and infiltrators, and works to reduce the number of persons staying unlawfully while protecting the rights of foreign workers.
The Labor Law Regulation and Enforcement Administration at the Ministry of Labor is empowered to impose administrative and criminal sanctions, including fines and the filing of indictments, on employers who violate labor laws.
Civil and Financial Consequences
Beyond criminal and administrative liability, employing shabachim also has serious civil and financial consequences:
Civil claims: The employer is exposed to civil claims over terms of employment and social benefits, even if the worker is a shabach. This is because these rights apply to all foreign workers, regardless of their legal status.
Financial losses: Closure of the business, whether by administrative or judicial order, leads to considerable financial losses and lost income.
Damage to reputation: A conviction for these offenses and the closure of the business seriously damage the business’s reputation.
Israel Tax Authority: Since the 2010 tax year, the Tax Authority has not recognized wage expenses relating to the employment of a foreign worker who is not employed lawfully. In addition, anyone caught employing a foreign worker unlawfully can expect a bookkeeping audit for tax purposes.
Forfeiture of money and assets: A court that has convicted a person of offenses of lodging and employing persons staying unlawfully may order, in addition to any penalty, the forfeiture of the payment he or she received or its monetary value.
Legal liability for these offenses is broad and cannot be transferred. Even if a contract was signed with a subcontractor placing responsibility on the subcontractor for the lawful status of the workers, this does not release the main contractor from criminal liability. Responsibility for what happens on the site rests with the person in charge of the construction project.
Moreover, the law provides that an officer of a corporation must supervise and do everything possible to prevent the offense of employing shabachim. In addition, the occupier of land will be deemed the employer of a foreign worker found working on the land, unless he or she proves otherwise.
This creates a broad web of liability, ensuring that many parties in the chain are exposed to sanctions, and requires careful due diligence at every level of business activity.
The Legal Assistance Required, and Tips for Employers
Dealing with suspicions or charges of employing persons staying unlawfully requires in-depth understanding of the law and the right legal assistance.
The Importance of Contacting an Expert Lawyer Immediately
Dealing with the complex bureaucratic and legal system on your own may lead to critical mistakes and to the rejection of applications or a conviction.
Professional legal assistance significantly increases the chances of success and saves valuable time and considerable resources.
In the event of a suspicion or a summons to questioning over employing, lodging, or transporting a shabach, you should contact a lawyer who specializes in criminal law and immigration law without delay.
An experienced lawyer may be able to secure a lighter sentence, reduce the penalty, and even have the charge dropped in light of the facts or the circumstances in which the offense was committed.
Legal Assistance at Different Stages of the Proceedings
At the investigation stage: It is very important to advise the suspects (project managers, work supervisors, contractors, business owners) before they give their version of events under questioning. Handling this stage correctly can significantly affect the rest of the proceedings.
Dealing with administrative or judicial closure orders: The closure of a business on the order of a police officer or another administrative body is not the end of the story. There are ways to challenge these decisions before the courts in an expedited proceeding.
In addition, it is possible to deal with the Israel Police and find a solution to almost any situation, based on an in-depth understanding of the legal procedures. A lawyer can examine the grounds for the order (for example, acting beyond authority, discrimination, extraneous considerations, or lack of good faith) and take action to have it canceled.
Representation in criminal proceedings: A criminal lawyer who specializes in this field can represent the defendant in court, present the circumstances of the case, argue for a lighter sentence or even an acquittal, and negotiate with the prosecution.
7 Important Tips for Employers:
To avoid getting into trouble with the law and its serious consequences, employers are advised to take the following steps:
- Thoroughly check the worker’s status: Before employing a foreign worker, carefully verify his or her legal status and the validity of his or her residence and work visa. Showing an identity card alone is not enough; ask for the specific entry and work permit and verify its validity with the Population and Immigration Authority.
- Keep careful records: Keep full records of all relevant documents, including work permits, employment contracts, pay slips, and confirmations of payment of social benefits. These records are essential in the event of an inspection or investigation.
- Respect workers’ rights: Even if, heaven forbid, a worker was employed without a permit, make sure to provide all the social benefits and terms of employment to which he or she is entitled under Israeli labor laws. Failing to provide these rights adds one offense to another.
- Do not hold passports: An employer may not hold a foreign worker’s passport.
- Recognize the breadth of liability: Understand that criminal and administrative liability for employing shabachim cannot be transferred to subcontractors or others. Liability applies to officers of the corporation and to occupiers of the land.
- Preventive legal advice: We recommend consulting a lawyer who specializes in immigration and labor law on an ongoing basis, to make sure you meet all the requirements of the law and to prevent problems in advance.
- Act quickly if there is a suspicion: If a suspicion arises or the enforcement authorities contact you, seek professional legal advice immediately. Acting quickly and correctly at an early stage can prevent the situation from getting worse.
Summary:
Employing persons staying in Israel unlawfully is a complex, multifaceted issue that carries serious legal, financial, and security risks. The analysis shows that the definition of a “person staying unlawfully” is broad, and that the legal framework, based mainly on the Entry into Israel Law and the Foreign Workers Law, places heavy responsibility on employers.
There is a clear and continuing trend toward harsher penalties, driven by security considerations. Offenses that were once considered a mere “misdemeanor” are now seen as a threat to national security, and this is reflected in actual prison sentences, heavy fines, administrative closure orders, and forfeiture of assets.
Moreover, the burden of proof rests on the employer, who must prove that he or she took all reasonable measures to verify that the worker is lawfully present. This liability is broad and cannot be transferred, and it extends to main contractors, officers of corporations, and even occupiers of land.
The paradox whereby foreign workers, including shabachim, are entitled to full labor rights in Israel exposes employers to a double risk: a criminal offense for the employment itself, and additional offenses for failing to provide these rights, in addition to exposure to civil claims.
For anyone suspected or accused of these offenses, the recommendation is to seek professional legal advice and assistance immediately. A lawyer who specializes in this field can assess the situation, guide the suspect at the investigation stage, represent him or her before the authorities and in the courts, and work to minimize the damage. Proactive, fast, and legally sound action is critical to protecting the rights and liberty of the person involved.
