Entry into and stay in the State of Israel are limited to a residence visa granted by the Minister of the Interior under the powers vested in him by the Entry into Israel Law, 5712-1952 (the “Entry into Israel Law“).
Accordingly, a worker from a foreign country who seeks to work in Israel must also obtain a special permit to do so. Violating the Entry into Israel Law and working in Israel without a permit is a criminal offense, and a foreign national who commits this offense may be held in custody until deportation or until alternative work is found.
In this article, we discuss the law that applies to the detention of foreign workers and the cases in which they can be released from detention, and we also present the relevant case law.
What Does the Entry into Israel Law Provide?
The Entry into Israel Law provides that a person who enters Israel and is not an Israeli citizen may stay in Israel only under a visa granted by the Minister of the Interior.[1] Among other things, the Entry into Israel Law provides that a visa may be granted for five days and up to three years.
A permit for permanent residence in Israel may also be granted.[2] A citizen of a foreign country who enters Israel and does not hold a valid residence visa, or any lawful residence visa at all, is in fact committing a criminal offense under the Entry into Israel Law,[3] and may be held in custody until removed from Israel or until released on bail.[4]
Moreover, the Entry into Israel Law sets out a special arrangement in Section 2(c) concerning residence visas and the employment of foreign workers in Israel, under which: “A visa and residence permit shall not be granted to a foreign worker […] unless the person seeking to employ the foreign worker holds a permit under Section 1M of the Foreign Workers Law, and the Minister of the Interior may determine that for foreign workers in certain positions he has set, or for types of workers he has set, the grant of a visa or residence permit does not require such a permit; the Minister of the Interior shall state the foreign worker’s field of occupation in the visa and residence permit granted to him.” To prevent exploitative employment of foreign workers, and also to prevent mass employment of foreign workers at the expense of Israeli workers, there is a special arrangement on this matter, as explained below.
It should be noted, however, that the core of the arrangement is set out both in the Entry into Israel Law and in the Foreign Workers Law, 5751-1991 (the “Foreign Workers Law”).
What Law Applies to a Foreign Worker?
As noted, a special arrangement applies to foreign workers, the core of which is set out in the Foreign Workers Law. The heart of the arrangement is the worker’s obligation to work for a specific employer, who also undertakes this obligation.
As part of the employer’s undertaking, the employer must ensure that the foreign worker is engaged in specific work, and undertake that the worker will not work for another employer.
In addition, there must be a written agreement between the employer and the foreign worker, which is submitted to the Ministry of the Interior as part of obtaining an employment permit (which the employer receives), and the employer must also arrange medical insurance for the foreign worker and provide suitable housing.
In fact, to employ a foreign worker in Israel, a permit is required from the Ministry of the Interior. This permit is not granted easily, and the Foreign Workers Law authorizes the Ministry of the Interior to weigh a variety of considerations, including the extent of the need in a specific industry.[5] Moreover, as a rule, the right to employ a foreign worker is not a vested right, and the tendency is in fact to reduce the number of foreign workers in Israel, as also stated in the Supreme Court’s judgment in the Sushimai case: “Government policy is to reduce the number of foreign workers in the country.
Therefore, as argued, the allocation of permits to employ foreign workers must be carried out according to precise and orderly procedures that, on the one hand, ensure that the principle of equality is upheld and, on the other hand, protect the State’s interest in not allowing the employment of foreign workers beyond the maximum number it wishes to permit.
Therefore, the respondents argue, every employer is required to submit an orderly application on time and in accordance with the procedure. In this context, they argue that the principle of equality requires a clear and unequivocal policy of strict adherence to submitting applications on time.”[6] It should also be emphasized that, given the strict conditions that must be met to obtain a permit to employ a foreign worker, a breach of any of the employer’s many obligations in this area is a criminal offense, and the Foreign Workers Law lists a host of offenses on the subject, from failing to arrange medical insurance to employment without a permit, and more.[7]
On the other hand, the Entry into Israel Law provides that the Minister of the Interior may extend a foreign worker’s residence visa for a period of up to five years for the purpose of his or her work.[8] In addition, a foreign worker is required to contact the Ministry of the Interior if he or she wishes to leave the employer.
In the past, such cases were governed by a procedure on foreign workers changing employers, which provided that once a foreign worker stopped working for a particular employer, he or she immediately became, in effect, a person staying in Israel unlawfully.
Although that procedure allowed the Ministry of the Interior to permit foreign workers to change employers, this was applied sparingly. The procedure in that form was struck down by the Supreme Court in the Kav LaOved case,[9] among other reasons because it was held to be disproportionate, since it in effect automatically stripped the foreign worker of his or her status.
Therefore, in place of the procedure that was struck down, a new procedure was established on updating foreign workers’ place of employment. The new procedure is more flexible than the old one, and its purpose is expressed, among other things, as follows: “In accordance with the Supreme Court’s judgment, the purpose of the procedure is to allow foreign workers to move easily and quickly from one employer to another within the same industry.
The procedure applies to foreign workers in the caregiving, agriculture, and manufacturing industries. This procedure applies to a worker who came to Israel to work in one of the industries to which it applies, for an employer holding a permit.” Under the new procedure, a worker who left his or her job or was dismissed will not be deported or lose his or her status for three months.
At the same time, the new procedure still requires a foreign worker to notify the Ministry of the Interior when he or she has left the workplace. The procedure also allows a foreign worker to move from one employer to another without limitation.
The procedure sets out the relevant arrangements for granting visas to a foreign worker who leaves his or her workplace, but it also authorizes the Ministry of the Interior, among other things, not to permit a stay in Israel where there is a concern for public safety, or where the foreign worker has broken Israeli law, and so on.
Even so, there are still many situations in which foreign workers are arrested and held in custody until they start working for another employer or until they are deported from Israel, as explained below.
What Are the Powers to Detain a Foreign Worker?
The Entry into Israel Law gives the Immigration Police broad powers to enforce the law, among other things to prevent the employment of foreign workers without a permit or without a workplace, contrary to the purpose of their entry into Israel.
The Entry into Israel Law therefore authorizes Ministry of the Interior inspectors or police officers to check residence permits where there are reasonable grounds to believe that a certain person is a foreign national without a residence visa, and to enter a residence where there is a suspicion that people without a lawful residence permit in Israel are present.[10]
If a worker is caught without a residence permit, he or she will be taken into custody, which is really a gentler word for “detention,” since it is detention in every sense. It should also be noted that the Entry into Israel Law authorizes a commissioner appointed by the Ministry of the Interior to order the release of a foreign worker on bail where the worker’s unlawful stay resulted from an error or occurred in good faith, or where there is no concern that the foreign worker will disappear when asked to leave Israel.
In addition, the Entry into Israel Law authorizes a commissioner to order the release of a foreign worker or a person staying in Israel unlawfully where, because of health or age, it would be preferable not to hold him or her in custody, or where the foreign worker has already been in custody for more than two months.[11]
Despite the authority of a Ministry of the Interior commissioner to order release on bail, there are cases in which a foreign worker will not be released from detention, for example: a foreign worker who does not cooperate with the authorities, or a concern for state or public security, and so on.
If a foreign worker is released on bail, he or she will receive a residence permit limited by conditions that such a commissioner is authorized to set for release on bail (for example, a guarantee from a third party, and so on).
Of course, a breach of the conditions of release on bail allows the worker to be detained again and returned to custody.
As for custody, there is a “Detention Review Tribunal,” whose role is to conduct judicial review of decisions on holding in custody a foreign worker or a person staying in Israel unlawfully, and to decide matters concerning the imposition of bail and the continued holding of a worker, or a person staying without a permit, within Israel.[12] The Detention Review Tribunal has the authority to order that a person be held in custody, while the Ministry of the Interior officer (the commissioner) has the authority to order release on bail. The law requires that a foreign worker be brought before the Tribunal no later than 96 hours after being detained.
The Detention Review Tribunal has many powers,[13] including: approving a custody order, cancelling a custody order, releasing on bail, changing bail conditions, and more. In addition, a foreign worker in custody may apply to the Tribunal at any time for further review of his or her detention conditions or the bail conditions imposed, and a person in custody has the right to be present at the hearing of his or her case.
An appeal against a decision of the Detention Review Tribunal may be filed with the district court sitting as a court for administrative affairs.[14]
The Legal Framework:
As a rule, the detention of any person, and all the more so of a foreign worker, must be carried out proportionately and reasonably. In the case of a foreign worker, it must be borne in mind that this is detention under the Entry into Israel Law, and the detention must therefore serve the purposes for which the Law was enacted, namely preventing unlawful stays, including unlawful work.
Therefore, where a foreign national can be released on bail and there is no justification for continued detention, a less drastic measure than detention should be preferred, as the Supreme Court held, for example:
“A person’s liberty, including the right to move about freely, is a fundamental right, and it may be taken away only under an explicit provision of law. According to the respondents’ position before us, the only source of authority for the petitioner’s detention is Section 13(c) of the Law.
Once it has been found that the petitioner’s continued detention does not serve the purpose for which his detention was permitted under Section 13(c), there is no longer any justification for continuing to hold him in detention.
In our case, the detention is by decision of an administrative authority, the Minister of the Interior, and care must be taken that the power vested in an administrative authority is exercised lawfully.
[…] An authority may use its legal power only to advance the purpose for which it was authorized to act. If the main purpose for which the authority exercised its power was not within the purposes for which it was authorized to act by law, the authority’s action will be considered an act beyond its authority.”[15]As noted, there is no doubt that foreign workers are a vulnerable population that must be protected all the more, and the court therefore has the authority and the duty to protect them with particular care.
This is what happened, for example, in the case of a foreign worker named Bernie Ker from the Philippines, who stopped working at a certain workplace and could not find another job.
The Ministry of the Interior hurried to detain him, and the Detention Review Tribunal imposed high bail conditions on the foreign worker, which in practice did not allow him to be released and find another job.
Among other things, the Ministry of the Interior argued that the petitioner in that case had acted contrary to the procedures concerning the transition period between leaving one employer and joining another.
However, those procedures had not been properly published, and there was a concern that the petitioner and many others like him were not aware of them at all. The District Court held:
“The exercise of the powers granted to the authorities with respect to ‘foreign workers’ must be carried out reasonably and to the proper extent. The relationship between the foreign worker and his employer must not turn the worker into someone at the employer’s mercy, without the ability to exercise his rights as a worker and as a human being!
The procedures prepared by the authority regarding the transition period between employers are intended to regulate the foreign worker’s status during this special period. An appropriate way should be found to bring these procedures to the attention of the foreign worker population, so that they can act in accordance with them and lawfully regularize their status.
At the same time, and until the publication of the procedures has been properly arranged, the authorities empowered to detain and hold foreign workers in custody should be instructed not to rush to take the drastic step of detention, and to make do with suitable alternatives that will allow the foreign worker’s ‘status’ to be regularized in accordance with the law.”[16]
The District Court held likewise in a petition filed in the Mohandas case, concerning a foreign worker from the Philippines who had indeed stayed in Israel for a long time without a permit after leaving her job.
She later began working for a woman with a head injury, and was told by the woman’s family that her work permit was being taken care of. Among other things, the court held that she should not be deported from Israel and should be allowed to earn a living with dignity.
In its decision, the court in this case, too, placed great emphasis on the vulnerability of the foreign worker population:
“In these circumstances, since this was the representation made to the petitioner and she acted on it, she cannot be held to account for not waiting for the respondent’s response, particularly since it may be assumed that she needed her work to support herself. Nor should it be forgotten that the petitioner cares for a woman with disabilities, who, together with her family members, is satisfied with her work.
Severing the relationship at this stage would also cause her suffering and distress. It must also be taken into account that the petitioner had not used up the entire period of stay permitted in Israel.”[17]
In Summary:
It seems that a foreign worker obtains a work permit in Israel only after a difficult process, and foreign workers whose only sin was wanting to work and earn a living with dignity in Israel may often find themselves behind bars.
Therefore, when a foreign worker is in detention, it is highly advisable to use the services of a lawyer experienced in Israeli immigration law, who will help secure release from detention and provide guidance in obtaining a lawful work permit.
[1] Section 1 of the Entry into Israel Law.
[2]Section 2 of the Entry into Israel Law, and also Section 3.
[3]Section 12(a) of the Entry into Israel Law.
[4]Section 13A of the Entry into Israel Law.
[5]Section 1M of the Foreign Workers Law.
[6]HCJ 3445/05 Sushimai 2004 Restaurant Ltd. v. Ministry of Industry, Trade and Labor – Auxiliary Unit (published in Nevo), para. E.
[7]Section 2 of the Foreign Workers Law.
[8]Section 3A of the Entry into Israel Law.
[9]HCJ 4542/02 Kav LaOved et al. v. Government of Israel et al., PD 61(1) 346.
[10]Section 13E of the Entry into Israel Law.
[11]Section 13F of the Entry into Israel Law.
[12]Section 13L of the Entry into Israel Law.
[13]Section 13O of the Entry into Israel Law.
[14]Section 13U of the Entry into Israel Law.
[15]HCJ 1468/90 Gideon Ben Israel v. Minister of the Interior, PD 44(4) 149, para. 5.
[16]AP (Jerusalem) 398/03 Ker v. Minister of the Interior, PD 5763 (2003) 218, para. 27.
[17]AP (Tel Aviv) 1248/08 Lina Mohandas v. State of Israel – Ministry of the Interior (published in Nevo), para. 12.
