The Graduated Procedure at the Ministry of the Interior: Introduction
If you have found love abroad and want to live together in Israel, you have probably already heard about the notorious bureaucracy involved.
Israel, not surprisingly, does not grant automatic citizenship to foreign partners of Israeli citizens. Instead, there is a lengthy “graduated procedure,” administered by the Ministry of the Interior, at the end of which permanent status or citizenship can be obtained.
This process may sound procedural and cold, but in practice it is a critical, life-defining route for many citizens who want to live lawfully in Israel with a foreign partner.
Below we explain precisely what the graduated procedure is, what its stages are, how it works for married couples compared with common-law couples, and what happens if, heaven forbid, the relationship ends partway through.
So What Is the Graduated Procedure for Regularizing a Partner’s Status?
The graduated procedure is an official procedure of the Population and Immigration Authority (Ministry of the Interior) intended to regularize, in stages, the legal status of foreign partners in Israel, on the basis of the Citizenship Law and the Entry into Israel Law.
The idea is simple: instead of immediately granting Israeli citizenship or permanent residency to a foreign partner, the State grants temporary status that is renewed stage by stage over several years.
During this period, it checks again and again that the two main conditions are met: (a) the relationship is real and sincere, and not, heaven forbid, “fictitious” in order to obtain status; and (b) there is no security or criminal bar to allowing the foreign partner to live in Israel (background checks and the like).
Only if the couple successfully completes all the stages of the procedure do they finally reach the finish line, where the foreign partner is entitled to permanent status: permanent residency or Israeli citizenship.
It is important to understand: the graduated procedure is not a punishment or a route designed just to give mixed couples the runaround. Its purpose is to protect both the State and the couples themselves.
For the State, it is a way to filter out sham marriages and fraud, since the authorities suspect about 5%-10% of marriages with foreign nationals of being fictitious.
For the couple, the process offers an opportunity to settle in gradually. Instead of jumping straight to citizenship, the partners live here for several years, build a center of life in Israel together (work, housing, friends), and only then make a final commitment to the State and to Israeli society.
It is a demanding and lengthy process, and at times it feels like an ongoing test of the relationship. Many couples describe the procedure as Sisyphean and stressful, sometimes even humiliating, with endless forms and meticulous officials, but they also say that at the end they felt an enormous sense of achievement and had the chance to open a new chapter in Israel.
It is important to note that the procedure applies to all mixed couples: married couples, unmarried couples (common-law partners), and even same-sex couples.
Israel recognizes its citizens’ right to a relationship with partners from abroad, whether or not they have an official marriage certificate.
Same-sex couples who married abroad, for example, can go through the graduated procedure just like any other married couple, and certain relief in the waiting period sometimes applies to them (according to Ministry of the Interior procedures).
The bottom line is that there is no discrimination in principle: anyone seeking to regularize status on the basis of a relationship with an Israeli will have to go through this graduated route, although its length and emphasis may vary depending on the type of relationship.
The Stages of the Graduated Procedure and the Visas You Will Receive Along the Way
The graduated route consists of several stages, and at each one the foreign partner receives a different type of visa, with gradually expanding rights and permits. We will describe the main stages in general terms, and then explain the differences between the track for married couples and the track for common-law partners:
Opening a File and Submitting an Application
The first stage takes place even before any visa is granted. The couple goes to the Ministry of the Interior (Population Authority) office in the Israeli citizen’s area of residence and submits a formal application to be recognized as a couple and to have the foreign partner’s status regularized.
At this stage, many documents must be presented: a marriage certificate (if any), birth certificates and personal status documents, foreign citizenship documents, clean criminal record certificates from the foreign partner’s country, proof of an ongoing relationship (correspondence, photos together, call history, letters from family and friends attesting to the relationship), as well as proof of a center of life in Israel (for example, a joint lease or joint ownership of an apartment, municipal tax, electricity, and water bills in both partners’ names, and so on).
Every document from abroad must be accompanied by a notarized translation and authenticated with an apostille or a chain of consular certifications, which surprises many couples the first time.
Already at the application stage, you can feel that this is bureaucracy of a different kind: dependence on hard-to-get official certificates, collecting receipts, and even WhatsApp screenshots (!!). Some couples feel their private lives are being intruded upon when they are required to reveal intimate correspondence and couple photos.
But all of this is meant to convince the Ministry of the Interior that your relationship is real and that you intend to settle in Israel together. After the application is submitted, the foreign partner is sometimes given a temporary permit to stay (for example, a B/2 tourist visa that does not permit work) so that he or she can remain in Israel until the application is decided, especially if the couple is already in Israel when they apply.
Keep in mind that staying unlawfully is prohibited: if the foreign partner stayed in Israel beyond the permitted period before submitting the application, it is advisable to deal with this promptly with a lawyer, because the Ministry of the Interior may put further obstacles in the way.
Review of the Application and the Couple’s Interview
After the documents are submitted, a review period begins in which the Ministry of the Interior conducts a comprehensive inquiry. This includes a couple’s interview, in which the partners are summoned to the office, sometimes together and sometimes separately, and bombarded with a host of personal questions.
The purpose of the interview is to examine the genuineness of the relationship: how long you have been together, how you met, and everyday details of your life together (who cooks, where you met each other’s families, what your dog is called, which side of the bed each of you sleeps on; yes, there are stories about questions like these!).
Sometimes you will also be asked about plans for the future, your familiarity with your partner’s culture and background, and more, all to make sure that you are a real couple running a shared household and not a couple “for appearances only.”
At the same time, the partners’ security and criminal backgrounds are checked. This is a nerve-racking period: even couples who truly love each other find themselves tense before the interview, worried about whether they have memorized enough matching details.
It is important to know that you are allowed (and it is even advisable) to come to the interview with an immigration lawyer, to make sure the questions are fair and that what is said is recorded correctly.
At this stage, the Ministry of the Interior may also require a financial guarantee where it has doubts: a demand to deposit a bank guarantee as a condition for granting the first visa, to deter breaches of the conditions of the procedure (for example, a guarantee that will be forfeited if it turns out that the relationship is fictitious and the foreign partner does not leave the country on time).
If the review stage ends successfully and the Ministry of the Interior is convinced that the relationship is genuine, a formal decision approving the application will be issued, and this is where the official “graduated procedure” actually begins.
We have written about the relationship genuineness assessment in detail here.
A Temporary Visa with a Work Permit
At the start of the graduated procedure, the foreign partner receives a temporary visa to stay and work. This will usually be a B/1 visa (a work visa in Israel) or a temporary A/5, depending on the track.
At this stage, the State does not yet issue a resident’s ID card with full rights, but it does allow the person to work and live lawfully.
For married couples, the first visa is usually a short B/1 visa, sometimes for six months or a year. This is a period in which the couple must begin building their life in Israel and continue to show that they are serious: finding work, perhaps starting to learn Hebrew, and of course continuing to live as a couple in every respect.
For common-law partners (unmarried couples), the Ministry of the Interior extends this stage: a B/1 visa is usually granted for a total period of up to 3 years, usually in one-year extensions.
Why the difference? Because there is no official marriage certificate, the State wants a longer trial period in which the couple proves its stability. These three years are a significant period in which an unmarried couple must show that they really live together in Israel over time, even without an “official seal” of marriage (we will expand below on the differences between the procedure for married couples and for common-law partners).
For the couple, the temporary visa period is a good time to demonstrate an intention to settle: finding a stable job (the foreign partner may now lawfully work in any job), renting an apartment long-term, opening a joint bank account, and so on. All of these will later be examined as proof of a shared center of life.
A Temporary Resident Visa (A/5)
After the initial temporary visa period, and provided everything is progressing properly, the foreign partner is upgraded to a higher status and receives an A/5 residence permit, that is, temporary resident status.
This is in effect a temporary Israeli ID card (different in color from a citizen’s blue ID card), which confers rights very close to those of a resident: the right to work without restriction, social rights such as National Insurance and state health insurance, and more.
For married couples, this stage comes fairly quickly: sometimes the foreign partner receives A/5 status almost immediately after the application is approved, and then a count of four years of temporary resident status begins.
In other words, unlike unmarried couples, who accumulate several years on a B/1 visa, a married couple may move almost immediately to “temporary resident” status and start counting 4 years from there.
For common-law partners, by contrast, the upgrade to A/5 comes only after 3 years in which the temporary work status was renewed every year. In other words, a common-law couple must go through the first three years of annual checks while the foreign partner holds only a work visa, and only after three years will he or she be granted temporary resident status for the fourth year onward.
We should emphasize that even during the period of temporary residency, the periodic review continues: every year, throughout the four years (for married couples) or the four additional years (for common-law partners), the couple will have to appear again at the Ministry of the Interior, submit updated documents proving that the relationship is still solid and that the shared center of life remains in Israel, and go through a short couple’s interview (again).
Some couples experience this as recurring stress: “Every year we sweat through the interview all over again, even though we’ve already been married for X years”, but this is part of the supervision policy.
Completing the Procedure: Permanent Residency or Citizenship
The finish line is approaching: after completing all the years of the graduated procedure, the couple can finally apply for permanent status.
For married couples, this is usually at the end of 4 to 5 years from the start of the procedure (depending on whether the initial work visa is counted or only the A/5 years). The couple may choose between applying for permanent residency for the foreign partner or applying for full Israeli citizenship.
For common-law partners, at the end of about 7 years of the process (3 years on a work visa plus 4 years on A/5), the next stage is permanent residency. Only after receiving permanent residency may a foreign partner who is not married to an Israeli citizen apply for naturalization (Israeli citizenship) through a separate track.
In other words, unmarried couples cannot apply for citizenship immediately at the end of the graduated procedure. They will first receive permanent resident status, which is a very strong status (a blue ID card) but without the right to vote or a passport.
After receiving permanent status, they can begin a naturalization process, which also requires meeting certain conditions (although in such cases the Ministry of the Interior usually tends to approve citizenship fairly easily, since the person has already lived in Israel for 7+ years as a recognized partner of an Israeli).
*Below we take a detailed look at the main differences between the two tracks of the graduated procedure: the track for married couples and the track for common-law couples. The distinction matters because, as we have already seen, the length of stay and the interim conditions differ, and each type of relationship has its own points of emphasis.
The Graduated Procedure for Married Couples
When a foreign partner is lawfully married to an Israeli citizen, the graduated procedure is structured so that Israeli citizenship for the foreign partner can be reached within about four and a half to five years.
The track is relatively shorter and simpler than for common-law partners, because the marriage itself serves as strong evidence of the intention to build a life together. However, this does not mean that the Ministry of the Interior “goes easy” on married couples; they will still undergo meticulous checks, just on a somewhat tighter schedule.
What Happens in Practice?
After the application is approved and the procedure begins, the married foreign partner usually receives a B/1 work visa for a short period (a few months to six months). This period allows the partner to start getting settled in Israel and allows for an initial review.
Fairly quickly, possibly already at the first annual visit to the Ministry of the Interior, the status is upgraded to A/5 (temporary resident), and from that point 4 years of temporary resident status are counted.
During these four years, as described, you must continue coming to the office once a year with proof that you still live together in Israel, go through an interview, and extend the visa for another year.
It is a bureaucratic process, but when the relationship is healthy and life is running normally, the annual visits become fairly routine. It is advisable to see them as an annual reminder that supervision is still in place, and to keep a binder of documents that you update every year (current bills, photos from the past year, perhaps letters from mutual friends, and so on).
Couples say that at first they were very stressed before each renewal, but after a year or two they gained confidence.
A useful tip: A day or two before the annual interview, sit down together over coffee and go over the basics: your exact address, the names of your coworkers, new hobbies you have taken up.
This refreshes your memory and ensures that if you are asked, you are both up to date on each other’s lives. It is not a trivia test, but officials sometimes ask specific questions just to make sure you are really involved in each other’s daily lives.
Completing the Track for Married Couples:
As noted, at the end of the four years of temporary residency (a total of about 4.5-5 years from the start of the procedure), you can apply for permanent status. Most married couples choose to apply for Israeli citizenship for the foreign partner.
The application is reviewed, and once it is approved, citizenship is granted, a short oath-taking ceremony (of loyalty to the State) is held, and the partner receives a blue ID card and an Israeli passport.
Some couples prefer to apply for permanent residency instead of citizenship, for various reasons: sometimes the foreign partner does not want an additional citizenship at this point, some countries may revoke their citizenship if Israeli citizenship is acquired, or the couple simply wants to postpone the step.
The Ministry of the Interior will allow you to choose this option, permanent residency, which is in effect a status with almost the same rights as citizenship (without a passport or the right to vote).
Even in the case of permanent residency, the graduated procedure ends successfully: once permanent status is granted, the foreign partner is free to live in Israel for good. And if he or she wishes to upgrade to citizenship in the future, the way is open (but requires a separate naturalization application).
An interesting point about married same-sex couples: In recent years, the Ministry of the Interior has recognized same-sex marriages performed abroad (Israel itself does not yet allow same-sex marriage, but it registers marriages performed abroad).
According to professionals in the field, the graduated procedure rules provide that for same-sex partners who are lawfully married to each other, a somewhat shorter procedure may be possible.
That is, after their application is approved, the route to permanent status may be shorter than four years. The interpretation is that the State understands the particular challenge these couples face and shows flexibility accordingly.
However, this has not been clearly published, and each case is examined on its merits. If you are a married LGBTQ couple, it is worth checking this with a lawyer or directly with the Immigration Authority; you may be able to shorten the wait compared with your straight friends.
The Graduated Procedure for Common-Law Partners (Unmarried Couples)
The track for regularizing the status of common-law partners is intended for partners who share a life but are not officially married. Israel recognizes such relationships for the purpose of granting status as well, but makes this conditional on a longer process and higher hurdles.
In fact, the graduated procedure for common-law partners takes about 7 years or even more until permanent status is obtained, followed by another separate stage if you want citizenship.
Why does the State make it harder? It is understandable: without a marriage certificate, it is relatively easy to make a false claim of a relationship. That is why a long waiting period is required, during which you will have to prove over time that you are truly partners in every sense.
What Is Different About This Track?
The burden of proof is higher from the moment the application is submitted: a common-law couple will have to provide solid evidence of the relationship, namely proof of a shared life for a significant period before the application.
The authorities usually want to see that you have been together for at least 6 months to a year before applying (although no official figure is written down, in practice a couple who have known each other for two weeks and apply for status will raise eyebrows).
You must show that you have lived under the same roof, run a shared household, and could in principle marry but chose not to (or could not, for some reason). Documents such as a joint lease, joint bills, photos from different periods of the relationship, and even affidavits from witnesses (friends, neighbors) confirming that you are common-law partners are all critical at the opening stage.
In some cases, the Ministry of the Interior may summarily reject a common-law couple’s application if it is convinced that the relationship does not meet the required standard of “a stable and long-term relationship.”
It is therefore advisable to come very well prepared from the outset with a rich file of documents, and not to skimp on details. Many unmarried couples seek professional advice just to prepare the initial application, because this is the most decisive step for them.
After the application is approved and the graduated procedure begins, the next significant difference is the length of the stages:
As we explained earlier, common-law partners must spend 3 years on a work visa (B/1). This means that for three full years the foreign partner is not entitled to Israeli social rights (beyond the right to work and live in Israel) and does not yet have an Israeli ID card.
These years can be somewhat frustrating, because a married couple would already have received temporary resident status with all its benefits at this stage. We have often met common-law couples who feel like “second-class citizens” during this period: for example, the foreign partner works and pays National Insurance contributions but is not personally entitled to state health insurance because she has no resident status; or the foreign partner cannot get a regular credit card because he has no Israeli ID number.
It takes patience, remembering that it is temporary, and supporting each other. The good news is that after three annual renewals (with all the paperwork and interviews involved), the A/5 stage finally arrives.
Once temporary residency is granted, life becomes easier: there is access to a health fund and social rights, and the foreign bride, for example, can receive a birth grant if a baby is born, and so on.
Completing the Track for Common-Law Partners
After completing the 7 years of the procedure (3 + 4), the couple is entitled to apply for permanent residency for the foreign partner. Permanent residency is a tremendous achievement: a person who came to Israel without any recognized status becomes the holder of stable status with an Israeli ID card.
It is important to note that the permanent residency of a common-law partner is not formally “conditional” on the continuation of the relationship, since it is an independent status. If, two years after receiving permanent status, the couple is no longer together, the status remains his or hers (except in extreme cases such as fraud).
What about citizenship? This is where the most striking difference lies: unlike married couples, who can receive citizenship immediately at the end of the procedure, common-law partners must submit a separate naturalization application only after they have permanent residency.
It is usually advisable to wait a certain period as a permanent resident (for example, a year or two) before applying for citizenship, in order to show continuity in the connection to Israel.
The law generally requires applicants for citizenship to prove that their center of life has been in Israel for several years, so a common-law partner who has already been in the process for 7 years certainly meets this requirement, but some of those years were without official status.
For this reason, the Ministry of the Interior sometimes prefers to see the person as a “permanent resident” for a little longer before granting citizenship. This is not official, but it is the practice. In short, if having an Israeli passport in hand matters to you, expect a longer overall timeline than for a married couple.
An important human point: Common-law couples always face the concern that they will be treated with excessive suspicion. There are many stories of officials asking, “So why didn’t you get married?” in a tone suggesting that you may be less serious.
Be mentally prepared for this question, and answer honestly and confidently about your decision; you have every right to choose the form of your relationship.
Some couples explain, for example, that they prefer a relationship without marriage for personal or ideological reasons, or because they come from previous marriages and do not want to marry again.
Any honest answer you give is fine; what matters is showing that you are together wholeheartedly. From other people’s experience, once the Ministry of the Interior understands that the relationship is stable (say, if you have a child together during the process, which is very significant proof of the genuineness of the relationship!), the attitude tends to improve.
Still, be prepared to be patient: this is a long-distance run, 7 years in which life changes (careers, children, moving house) and each time you need to document and prove things. But many have gone through it successfully before you.
Try to see each year that passes as a small victory: another stamp in the passport, another step toward the goal where you will be free of all the bureaucracy.
And What If the Relationship Ends in the Middle of the Graduated Procedure?
The most painful issue is the possibility that love itself will not survive the obstacle course. Life is complicated, and unfortunately some couples who start the graduated procedure together discover at some point that the relationship has come to an end, whether by agreement (separation) or through a formal divorce.
There are also tragic cases in which the Israeli partner dies during this period. What happens then to the foreign partner, who pinned his or her hopes on a life in Israel? Is everything cancelled at once?
The Ministry of the Interior’s official answer is: termination of the procedure. That is, once the basis (the relationship) ceases to exist, there are no grounds for continuing to grant status to the foreign partner. In practice, visa renewals will usually stop, and the foreign partner may be required to leave Israel within a short time.
However, and this is an important “however,” this is not an irreversible decree in every situation. There are special procedures and solutions for such situations, and in recent years both the courts and the Ministry of the Interior have shown greater flexibility toward foreign partners who separated after a period in Israel.
First, we should distinguish between two situations: (1) the couple separated or divorced; (2) the Israeli partner died. In addition, it matters whether there are children in common.
Separation or Divorce During the Procedure:
With children in common: If the couple has one or more Israeli children in common, the State recognizes that it has a responsibility toward the children’s best interests not to separate them from a parent.
Under the procedure, if at the time of the separation the foreign partner had held A/5 status (temporary resident) for at least two years, his or her situation is relatively better.
In such a case, the foreign partner can ask to continue the procedure on humanitarian grounds, in order to remain in Israel near his or her young child. There is no automatic guarantee that the request will be granted, but the chances are much higher.
In fact, if the relationship broke up after 2+ years as a temporary resident, the Ministry of the Interior tends to allow the process to continue until permanent status is granted, understanding that the person is already rooted here as the parent of an Israeli child.
Where there are children, the procedure in effect “changes tracks”: instead of examining the genuineness of the relationship, the authorities examine the child’s best interests. Of course, it will be necessary to prove that the foreign parent really takes part in the child’s life, that there are visitation arrangements, and so on. But as a rule, a child in common is a very strong card for having the request to continue status approved.
Without children: Here things get complicated. When a separation occurs and there are no children connecting you, the foreign partner’s status depends entirely on the relationship, and once it is gone, he or she has no vested right to remain.
In this situation, the Ministry of the Interior will usually terminate the procedure and ask the foreign partner to leave, and the foreign partner is left with only one option: applying to the Ministry of the Interior’s humanitarian committee.
This is a special inter-ministerial committee that examines exceptional cases for granting status on compassionate grounds. A separated foreign partner can try to show that there are special humanitarian circumstances that make it fair to allow him or her to remain: for example, that he or she has lived in Israel for many years, has integrated well, has almost no ties to the country of origin, or perhaps that his or her medical or mental condition would deteriorate if deported now.
The committee will examine each case on its merits. In all honesty, without children, the chance of receiving status after a separation is quite low, especially if you were only at the beginning of the procedure.
But if the separation happened at a truly advanced stage (for example, a few months before permanent status was due to be granted), and there is evidence that the foreign partner is already very much part of society here, there have been precedents in which the partner still received residency on grounds of fairness, because cutting him or her off at that point would have been too cruel.
Death of the Israeli Partner
This is a most unfortunate situation, and the State treats it with a little more sensitivity than a voluntary separation, but the principle is similar: once the relationship has been cut short, there is no automatic basis for continuing the status. Here too, the treatment differs:
If there are children in common: The situation is very similar to a separation with children, except that in these tragic circumstances there is no minimum period requirement in temporary status.
In other words, even if, heaven forbid, the Israeli partner died early in the process, the foreign partner, who is now the sole parent of Israeli children, can certainly apply and receive continued status.
The Ministry of the Interior will probably grant residency, because the children’s best interests are clear: they will not deport the children’s parent.
And if there are no children in common: In such a situation, the foreign partner will be assessed according to the length of stay and the degree of integration. The procedures provide that if the foreign partner had held A/5 status for at least two years before the death, and can prove that his or her center of life is rooted more in Israel than in the country of origin, there is a chance that the case will be referred to the humanitarian committee with a positive recommendation.
A “strong connection to Israel” is measured by a range of factors: whether the foreign partner has close family in Israel (for example, perhaps you already have an Israeli family and friends to whom he or she is attached), whether he or she speaks Hebrew, has worked here for a long time, and owns assets here compared with very few abroad, and more.
The more convinced the authorities are that the person is already “almost Israeli,” the more inclined they will be to grant status on humanitarian grounds, even though the relationship was cut short in sad circumstances.
