The police arrive, find workers without permits, and a few hours later an order is posted on the door requiring the business to close for 30 days.
This is happening more and more often. Enforcement in this area increased significantly in 2024-2025, with targeted raids across the country that shut down bakeries, restaurants, event halls, and other businesses.
Anyone who receives such an order faces immediate damage: lost income, broken relationships with clients, and a complete shutdown of operations, sometimes without even one day’s warning.
What Is a Business Closure Order for Employing People Staying in Israel Unlawfully?
The Entry into Israel Law, 5712-1952, prohibits employing anyone who is in Israel without a valid residence visa. A person staying in Israel unlawfully, known in official Hebrew terminology as a shabach (a Hebrew acronym for “person staying unlawfully”), is mainly a Palestinian resident of Judea, Samaria, or Gaza who has entered Israel and works without a permit issued by the Coordination and Liaison Administration.
The term also applies to any foreign worker whose residence or work visa has expired, whether they came from Ghana, Moldova, or any other country.
When the police carry out a raid and find people staying in Israel unlawfully, a police officer is authorized to issue an order restricting the use of the business premises, in other words, to close the business.
The order can be issued even before an indictment is filed and without any conviction. It is administrative, takes effect immediately, and can come within a few hours of the raid.
Employing, lodging, and transporting people staying in Israel unlawfully are criminal offenses. In addition to the closure order, the business owner may be investigated and face an indictment, heavy administrative fines, and, in serious cases, even up to 4 years in prison. Responsibility lies with the employer, even if it was the worker who initiated contact.
Notably, since October 7 the authorities have stepped up enforcement and do not hesitate to impose closure orders on businesses that employ such workers. Enforcement actions have become markedly more aggressive, and there is a clear determination to do everything possible to combat the practice.
The Factors Taken Into Account
Issuing the order requires the exercise of discretion, at least according to the law. The police officer must examine the circumstances before signing, and in practice the factors that carry weight are:
- Knowledge and awareness: Did the business owner know that the worker was staying without a permit? Did the worker present documents in order to mislead? The difference between a knowing offense and a deception the employer could not possibly have detected changes the entire course of the case.
- Previous enforcement history: The business’s history plays a role. A business owner facing enforcement action for the first time is in a different position from an owner whose business has previously been found to employ people staying in Israel unlawfully.
- Scale: One worker whose employment appeared to be lawful is not the same as ten people staying in Israel unlawfully who were given lodging on the premises. The number of people involved and the circumstances in which they were found directly affect how severe the decision will be.
- The harm caused by closure: A seasonal business closed at the height of its season, a business whose lawfully employed staff would be hurt, contracts with clients that could not be fulfilled: all of these factors are part of the exercise of discretion.
- How the person came to be on the premises: Was the person actively employed and paid, or found sleeping on the premises without having been paid anything? The distinction is not always clear, but it can change the picture.
Using these factors effectively and at the right time (even before the order is issued, and certainly immediately afterward) is the core of the legal work in these cases.
How Long Can a Business Be Closed, and What Is the Difference Between an Administrative and a Judicial Order?
The Business Licensing Law, 5728-1968, sets out two tracks that are important to understand, because the way to challenge each one is completely different.
An administrative closure order (Sections 20-21 of the Law) is issued by a police officer, a local authority, the Ministry of Labor, or other bodies. It is limited to 30 days but can be extended: if the issuing authority files a motion with the court to extend it, the order automatically remains in force for another 7 days until a decision is made, and the court may extend it with no time limit. If an indictment has been filed, the order may remain in force until the end of the proceedings.
A judicial closure order is more severe. It is issued by the court at one of three stages: before an indictment is filed (Section 22B), when the indictment is filed (Section 17), or at sentencing (Section 16). In the last case, the order may even be permanent.
The practical difference also lies in how you challenge the order: for an administrative order, you file a motion to cancel it in the Magistrates’ Court; for a judicial order, you file an appeal.
Received a Closure Order? How to Request Its Cancellation, a Shorter Closure, or a Change in Its Terms
Act on Both Tracks at Once, and Immediately
As soon as the order is issued, pursue both avenues simultaneously: approach the issuing authority and apply to the court. There is usually no reason to choose only one.
Approaching the issuing authority: Whoever issued the order (the police officer, the local authority, or the Ministry of Labor) is also authorized to cancel it. This is the fastest route, yet most business owners never even try it.
A well-organized written request, supported by facts that demonstrate good faith, creates pressure and is sometimes enough on its own. At the very least, it creates a record that can be used at the court hearing.
Filing a motion to cancel the order in court under Section 22 of the Business Licensing Law: the hearing is scheduled within 7 days. However, filing the motion alone does not suspend the order. Together with the motion to cancel, you must explicitly request a temporary stay of enforcement of the closure order pending the hearing.
The court is authorized to grant a stay when the harm caused by the closure is clear and the arguments for cancellation deserve to be heard. A business owner who applies to cancel the order but fails to request a stay must keep the business fully closed for an entire week, even though both requests could have been made in the same document.
The Arguments Available to the Business Owner
The court will cancel an administrative order when one of three grounds is present. It is important to raise as many of them as possible at the same time: even if only one is accepted, that is enough.
First ground: the business acted lawfully (the good-faith argument). This is usually the strongest argument. The court examines: Did the business owner check the worker’s documents? What was presented as proof of status? Did the owner have any reason to doubt it?
What to prepare: the identification documents the worker presented (ID card, work permit, visa), even if they turn out to be forged; employment agreements, pay slips, and any document showing that the employment was, on its face, lawful. The more thorough the documentation, the stronger the argument.
A point that is often missed: even if the work permit the worker presented was forged, the employer’s liability is reduced when the forgery could not have been detected through a reasonable check. The court has examined cases in which forged documents appeared legitimate in every respect and has rejected the claim that the employer was required to detect them.
Second ground: the legal requirements for issuing the order were not met. The legislature required the authority to weigh several factors before issuing the order: the business owner’s knowledge, the severity of the violation, and whether closure is proportionate.
When an order is issued without any record of this exercise of discretion, it is open to cancellation. What to examine: Did the police officer document the reasons for the decision?
Did the officer check whether the business owner knew? Were alternatives considered? A lack of documentation is a legal defect.
Third ground: administrative law grounds. These are four independent grounds, each of which stands on its own:
- Acting beyond authority: Was the person who signed the order authorized to do so? The law defines the specific officer rank that has the authority to issue this type of administrative order.
- Discrimination: Were other businesses found employing people staying in Israel unlawfully under similar circumstances allowed to stay open? Discrimination between similar businesses is an independent ground for cancellation.
- Extraneous considerations: Was the order issued for reasons unrelated to the purpose of the law?
- Violation of the rules of natural justice: a hearing that was not granted, a decision without stated reasons, proportionality that was not examined. If no hearing was granted at all, that alone is an independent ground for cancellation, regardless of the other arguments.
Changing the Terms of the Order, and What a Lawyer Prepares in Such a Case
A motion to cancel can also include a request to change the terms of the order. You can ask to reopen the business for part of its activity, to shorten the closure period, or for approval of essential work that will prevent irreversible harm to clients.
The court has the power to modify the order, not only to cancel it. Sometimes a partial change is much easier to obtain than full cancellation, and in certain cases it is the best practical outcome that can be achieved.
The first steps in such a case:
- Collecting all the identification documents the worker presented, before anyone files anything.
- Reviewing the raid report: whether one exists and what it states.
- Checking whether a hearing was granted. Is it documented? How long did it last, and what was said?
- Checking the authority of the person who signed the order.
- Filing a motion for a stay of enforcement immediately, together with the motion to cancel.
- Preparing a detailed affidavit from the business owner: the employment history, the documents that were presented, and what the owner did and did not know.
Each of these steps is both preparation for the hearing and early pressure on the issuing authority, which sometimes leads to a solution before the case ever reaches court. And pressure of this kind, when it comes from a law firm with a well-organized factual record, usually works.
Summary
A business owner who receives an administrative closure order faces two proceedings at once, each requiring a different strategy: the administrative proceeding, which concerns cancellation of the order and requires action within a few days, and the criminal proceeding, which comes later and deals with the question of liability.
The most common mistake is to focus all attention on the criminal investigation and leave the administrative order unaddressed, then arrive at the court hearing without documents, without a request for a stay of enforcement, and without a well-organized argument.
Separating the two proceedings, and knowing what each one requires at the right stage, is the first thing a lawyer explains to a client who walks in with an order in hand.
