“Utah marriage” is a marriage performed by videoconference, with both spouses appearing before an authorized officiant in the State of Utah in the United States. This allows couples from all over the world, including couples from Israel, to marry from where they live in a civil wedding without having to leave Israel and travel physically to the State of Utah.
This innovative rule was recently established by the Supreme Court (in AAA 7368/22 and AAA 7375/22 Ministry of the Interior v. Adi Brill et al.), sitting as an appellate court over a series of judgments of the administrative courts, after the State appealed against rulings holding that the registration officer cannot refuse to register a couple who married in Utah via Zoom on the grounds that most of the connections indicate that the ceremony was performed in Israel rather than in Utah, since the couple were physically in Israel at the time of the ceremony. This is because the “place where the ceremony is performed” in the digital age raises a complex question that has not yet been answered by legislation or case law, and the registration officer has no statutory authority to consider or decide it. As was written there:
“Having found that the question of the place where the marriage ceremony was performed in the circumstances before us raises extremely complex questions, questions that the registration officer should not decide, and since it is not disputed that the respondent couples submitted to the registration officer a marriage certificate drawn up in accordance with the law of the State of Utah, the necessary conclusion is that the registration officer must register the couples as married.”
It was held that where a proper public certificate of the State of Utah is placed before the registration officer, attesting to the performance of an official and valid marriage ceremony, the officer must register the couple named in the certificate as married in the Population Register in Israel.
The Supreme Court relied on the Funk-Schlesinger rule (HCJ 143/62), which held as early as 1963 that the registration officer at the Ministry of the Interior may not exercise substantive discretion on the question of whether a marriage is religiously or legally valid, but must limit himself to checking only the formal validity of a marriage certificate lawfully issued in a foreign country.
This means that in Israel there is a duty to register in the Population Register every couple who presents an official, valid marriage certificate issued in another country. This rule formed the main legal foundation for the innovative ruling that recognized Utah marriages.
The Innovation in the Ruling and Its Implications for Civil Marriage in Israel
The main innovation in the Supreme Court’s judgment is that, until that judgment, it was possible to marry in Israel only under religious law, and the Ministry of the Interior did not recognize marriages of Israeli couples before a competent authority abroad as long as the couple were in Israel at the time of the ceremony. Anyone who wanted a civil marriage had to leave the country and marry in a country that performs civil marriages, in accordance with local law.
From the Supreme Court’s ruling, which upheld the registration of Utah marriages, it emerges that the law and the case law do not distinguish between Utah marriages and any other civil wedding performed abroad, and as far as they are concerned, even if the couple were physically in Israel while the ceremony was performed via Zoom with the State of Utah, there is still no ruling determining, in the digital age, where a digital ceremony takes place: here in Israel or in the State of Utah.
Therefore, Utah marriages are now recognized in Israel as well, and even if the Israeli couple are physically in Israel when the marriage ceremony is performed via Zoom, the registration officer will register them in the Population Register as married.
It is estimated that there are hundreds of thousands of Israelis who could not marry in Israel in a religious ceremony, whether because they are defined as having no religion, are same-sex couples, underwent a Reform conversion, or are forbidden to marry under religious law.
The judgment means that these couples, as well as any couple who do not wish to marry in a religious ceremony, can now marry through “Utah marriage,” and the Supreme Court has in effect opened the possibility for Israeli couples to have a civil marriage in Israel, online, without leaving the country.
Note: It is important to emphasize that although registering a “Utah marriage” in Israel gives the couple formal status as married in the Population Register, it does not guarantee an immediate solution to all the legal issues related to personal status in Israel.
For example, in the event of divorce, inheritance, or disputes concerning property and social rights, legal questions may arise as to the validity of the marriage and its practical consequences. It is therefore advisable for couples who married through Utah marriage to seek professional legal advice to help them prepare appropriately for such situations and prevent potential disputes.
The Utah Marriage Ceremony Process
The Utah marriage ceremony involves several bureaucratic stages: a marriage license must be obtained in accordance with Utah law, a date must be set for the Zoom ceremony before an authorized officiant, and two witnesses must be arranged to be present at the ceremony. After the date of the ceremony is set, the couple receives a videoconference link for the scheduled date, which they can share with all their guests at the ceremony.
After the ceremony, the marriage certificate must be issued and signed by the officiant and the two witnesses. A digital marriage certificate is issued immediately after the ceremony (and is immediately valid in the United States), and an original marriage certificate is also issued and signed, in addition to the officiant and the witnesses, by the county clerk in the State of Utah where the ceremony was performed. The original marriage certificate is then sent for signature by the Lieutenant Governor of the State of Utah with an apostille (an international certification that authenticates the signatures on a public document).
The signed original certificate will then be ready to be sent to the married couple. It is usually sent to the law firm representing the couple in Israel and to the couple’s address.
The married couple must then take the marriage certificate to the Ministry of the Interior office in their area and submit it to the Population Register registration officer in order to be registered as a married couple.
Organizing a Utah marriage ceremony is relatively simple and requires little effort from the couple, and about a month after the ceremony the marriage certificate reaches the couple for submission to the Ministry of the Interior.
The costs of Utah marriage are also moderate compared with the other options available to couples. Beyond the cost of the fees and the required certifications, civil marriages involve travel expenses abroad for both spouses to hold the ceremony (in Cyprus, for example), or the costs involved in “Paraguay marriages,” which require at least one of the spouses to be present at the ceremony in Paraguay, making the whole marriage process much more expensive.
The Utah Marriage Process: Stages, Costs, and Timeframes:
Below is an accurate, detailed breakdown of the stages of the process, including associated costs and realistic timeframes for completing it:
Stage one: applying for a marriage license:
At this stage, an online application must be submitted on the official website of Utah County (the “Utah County Clerk”), with identification by means of a valid passport or an international driving license (a clear photo and a high-quality scan). A selfie of both spouses must be attached for additional verification. After completing the application, you will be asked to pay a fee of $71.
Stage two: scheduling the date and the online marriage ceremony:
After receiving confirmation of the license (usually sent by email within one business day), the date of the Zoom ceremony must be coordinated with a licensed officiant on behalf of Utah County. When scheduling the ceremony, you must provide the names and identification details of two witnesses over the age of 18 (passport or driving license), who will be present online during the ceremony.
The ceremony itself costs $35. It is conducted in English and lasts about 20 minutes on average. It can be held from anywhere in Israel as long as there is a stable internet connection.
Stage three: issuing the marriage certificate and apostille:
At the end of the ceremony, an initial digital marriage certificate is issued for the couple. For the certificate to be officially recognized in Israel, the official marriage certificate must be ordered from Utah County, authenticated with an apostille, which is an international certification of the document’s authenticity. The apostille costs $30, plus a handling fee of $15.
Stage four: shipping and receiving the original certificate in Israel:
The authenticated certificate is sent by secure international mail (FedEx or a similar service). Shipping usually costs about $75. The estimated time for the authenticated original certificate with the apostille to arrive is about two weeks to a month from the date of the ceremony.
Stage five: registering the marriage in Israel:
After receiving the certificate, the couple must appear in person at the Population Register office (Ministry of the Interior) nearest to where they live and submit the original certificate with the apostille, the original identity cards of both spouses, and a change of personal status form. The certificate does not need to be translated, since it is in English. Registration in the Population Register is usually done on the spot or within a few days.
Summary of costs and timeframes:
Total costs: about $226 (about NIS 800).
Timeframes: Receiving the marriage license: one business day. Zoom marriage ceremony: immediate, subject to availability in the online calendar. Receiving the original certificate and apostille in Israel: about two weeks to a month.
To make the process efficient and avoid delays and surprises, couples usually seek the help of law firms in Israel that handle civil marriages and are experienced in arranging Utah marriages, and that work with law firms in the State of Utah. These firms take care of preparing and submitting the documents and obtaining the marriage license at the first stage, as well as scheduling the marriage ceremony with an authorized officiant and arranging the two witnesses required for the ceremony, all the way until the original certificate reaches Israel and the couple, signed with an apostille and ready to be submitted to the Ministry of the Interior.
