As in every country in the world, entering Israel requires a visa, whether obtained before arriving in Israel or upon landing at Ben Gurion Airport (or at one of the country’s seaports).
There are many types of visas granted to foreign nationals. In this article, we discuss the types of visas, and in particular the visa known as the “B/1” visa (or B1 visa), which is in fact a visitor visa that gives its holder the right to work in Israel. In other words, it is a visa granted to temporary workers, as explained below.
The Law on Entry into Israel:
Entering Israel requires a visa and passage through an official border crossing. The requirement to obtain a residence visa in Israel is set out in the Entry into Israel Law, 5712-1952 (the “Entry into Israel Law”). The Law provides that
“(a) A person who is not an Israeli citizen shall enter Israel under an oleh visa or under a visa pursuant to this Law. (b) A person who is not an Israeli citizen or the holder of an oleh visa or an oleh certificate shall reside in Israel under a residence permit pursuant to this Law.”
An oleh visa is granted to those entitled to immigrate to Israel by virtue of being Jewish, under the Law of Return, 5710-1950. The Entry into Israel Law, on the other hand, deals, as noted, with visas granted “under the Law,” and the visas granted to nationals of foreign countries include those set out in Section 2 of the Entry into Israel Law:
“(a) The Minister of the Interior may grant (1) a visa and permit for transit residence, for up to five days; (2) a visa and permit for visitor residence, for up to three months; (3) a visa and permit for temporary residence, for up to three years; (4) a visa and permit for permanent residence; (5) a temporary permit for visitor residence to a person who is in Israel without a residence permit and against whom a removal order has been issued, until his departure from Israel or his removal from it. (b) A visa and permit for transit residence or visitor residence may be granted to a group of persons jointly.”
A broader description of the types of visas granted is found in the Entry into Israel Regulations, 5734-1974 (the “Entry into Israel Regulations”). These Regulations include a list of countries whose nationals must obtain a visa in their country of origin, as well as the types of visas that exist (there are tourist visas, that is, visitor visas, and visas for temporary residence in Israel, as explained below).
We should also note that under the Entry into Israel Law, the Minister of the Interior has the authority to extend a person’s period of stay in Israel, under Section 3 of the Law.
Interim summary: like every country in the world, Israel guards its borders and regulates how people enter and stay in the country, both for security reasons (that is, to prevent hostile elements from entering) and to prevent unlawful stays in Israel and settlement there without supervision and prior checks.
Residence Visas in Israel:
Residence visas are in fact divided into two groups. The first group is “visitor visas,” which are designated by the Hebrew letter for B. The second group is visas for temporary residence in Israel, which are designated by the Hebrew letter for A (from the Hebrew word for “temporary”).
In the first group, there is a visitor visa called B/1, a work permit for a foreign worker, which is the subject of this article and which we discuss in more detail below. At the same time, and to understand the full picture, there is a visitor visa called B/2, which is in fact the most common tourist visa and is usually granted to people who come to Israel for a visit. Regulation 5(b) of the Entry into Israel Regulations governs the B/2 visa and provides:
“A person who seeks to enter Israel for a visit or for any other purpose requiring only a short stay in Israel, except for the purpose of work, whether paid or unpaid, shall apply for a B/2 (tourist) visitor residence visa and permit.”
Incidentally, we should make clear at this point that, unlike the B/1 visa discussed in this article, the B/2 visa does not give its holder the right to work in Israel. In addition, the B/2 visa is limited to a period of up to three months, although the Minister of the Interior has the authority to extend it in certain cases.
Nationals of some countries must obtain a B/2 entry visa in advance, while still in their country of origin. Regulation 3 of the Entry into Israel Regulations sets out the countries from which it is possible to enter without a visa in advance, including Italy, the United States, Canada, and Hungary.
However, even where no visa is needed in advance, the Israeli border control officer is authorized to refuse entry under the Entry into Israel Law if a concern arises in the circumstances of the case.[1]
Another entry visa for tourists is the B/3 visa, which applies to people who come to Israel without a specific reason. In the Entry into Israel Regulations, therefore, a person who receives this type of permit is referred to as an “uncertain entrant.”
This permit applies to people whose status for purposes of entering or residing in Israel is unclear. It is limited to one month only. Moreover, a person who enters Israel on a B/3 visa must apply to the Ministry of the Interior to clarify his or her status.
This visa usually focuses on people who do intend to immigrate to Israel, but whose personal situation is not sufficiently clear and does not allow a superficial check (for example, people whose Jewishness is uncertain who wish to settle in Israel, and others).
Another tourist visa is the B/4 visa, which applies to volunteers. People from all over the world come to Israel to volunteer on kibbutzim, in agriculture, with certain nonprofit organizations, and so on. For the avoidance of doubt, a person who enters Israel on a B/4 visa may not work for pay.
Another visa, added about two years ago, is the B/5 visa, which is granted to investors who come to Israel to establish ventures or invest money in Israeli ventures. The purpose of this visa is to encourage financial investment in Israel. The children and spouse of a person entitled to a B/5 visa may also receive a B/52 residence visa.
Alongside visitor visas, there is also the group of visas for temporary residence in Israel. The A/1 visa is intended for those eligible under the Law of Return who wish to stay in Israel before making a final decision on aliyah, and it also carries the right to work.
The A/2 visa is granted to pupils and students studying in Israel and usually does not carry the right to work, while their relatives may sometimes be granted an A/4 visa. The A/3 visa is intended for clergy who come to Israel for a religious mission or position.
The A/5 visa is usually granted to those in the process of regularizing their status in Israel, such as spouses of Israelis and their children, and it also carries the right to work in Israel.
Work Permits for Foreign Workers in Israel:
So far we have discussed the types of visas that exist, but everything said so far mostly applies to tourists or to people who come to Israel for specific purposes. However, the B/1 visa is not a visa for tourists as such, but for people who come to Israel to work; in other words, a work permit for foreign workers.
Israel, like every modern state with a modern economy, seeks to maintain balance in the labor market. To this end, it encourages studies and professional training in certain fields, and sometimes it also allows foreign workers to come to Israel and work in fields where there are not enough “working hands,” for example caregiving, construction, and so on.
The Entry into Israel Law regulates how people enter Israel, but regarding work permits for foreign workers, Section 2(c) provides as follows:
“A visa and residence permit shall not be granted to a foreign worker as defined in Chapter D1 of the Foreign Workers Law, 5751-1991 (in this Law, the Foreign Workers Law), unless the person seeking to employ the foreign worker holds a permit under Section 1M of the Foreign Workers Law, and the Minister of the Interior may determine that for foreign workers in certain positions he has set, or for types of workers he has set, the grant of a visa or residence permit does not require such a permit; the Minister of the Interior shall state the foreign worker’s field of occupation in the visa and residence permit granted to him.”
This tells us that there is a specific law for foreign workers, the Foreign Workers Law, 5751-1991 (the “Foreign Workers Law”). Under Section 3A of the Entry into Israel Law, the Minister of the Interior may grant a residence visa in Israel (the B/1, as noted) for a longer period than other tourist visas, namely for a period of 5 years.
It should also be noted that for foreign workers in the caregiving sector, their stay may be extended beyond five years, one additional year at a time, under Section 3A(b) of the Entry into Israel Law.
But that is not all: a person who wants to employ a foreign worker must obtain a specific permit to do so, a work permit for a foreign worker, under the Foreign Workers Law.
To obtain a permit, the employer must present a medical certificate showing that the worker does not have any disease that could endanger the public,[2] present a written contract between the worker and the prospective employer,[3] define exactly what the worker’s job will be, provide suitable housing for the worker,[4] arrange medical insurance for the worker, and more.
It should also be noted that under the Foreign Workers Law, there is a commissioner at the Ministry of Industry, Trade and Labor whose role is to investigate complaints by foreign workers.[5] There is no doubt, then, that the Foreign Workers Law was intended to protect their rights, since foreign workers are naturally a far more vulnerable population that does not know the language or Israeli law and is naturally more exposed to exploitation by prospective employers.
It should also be noted that a foreign worker who finishes working for a particular employer must notify the Ministry of the Interior, after which the worker has a period of three months in which he or she may look for another employer. Incidentally, foreign workers used to be bound to their employers, but this arrangement was struck down by a ruling of the Supreme Court.[6]
A B/1 (B1) Work Visa for a Foreign Worker:
As noted, an employer who wants to employ a foreign worker must have a permit or work visa for the foreign worker under the Foreign Workers Law, and at the same time the employer, and the worker as well, may apply in advance to allow the worker to enter Israel.
Moreover, as part of obtaining the permit under the Foreign Workers Law, the employer must also present confirmation from the Ministry of the Interior that the worker will be allowed to enter Israel.[7]
The complementary provision on this subject is found in Regulation 5(a) of the Entry into Israel Regulations, which provides: “A person who seeks to enter Israel in order to work there temporarily for pay shall apply for a B/1 (temporary worker) visitor residence visa and permit; an employer in Israel may submit such an application on behalf of a foreign resident whom he wishes to employ.”
It should also be emphasized that a person who comes to Israel with another visa cannot change his or her existing visa to a B/1 visa, unlike with other visas.
Moreover, foreign workers often live in Israel for a long time and, naturally, want to go on vacation to their country of origin. For this purpose, the Ministry of the Interior has a procedure on handling re-entry visas to Israel for foreign workers who are lawfully in Israel and wish to go abroad and return.
For the worker to be able to return to Israel, he or she must present confirmation from the employer, pay a fee, and apply in accordance with the procedure. There is also a requirement that the worker have at least 90 days remaining on his or her residence visa in Israel. Applications for a re-entry visa for a foreign worker are therefore very common among Israeli employers.
Naturally, foreign workers living in Israel meet partners and even have children. Unfortunately, today there are many children of foreign workers who in fact have no status. This is because Regulation 12 of the Entry into Israel Regulations provides that the status of children of foreign workers, and of foreign nationals in general, is the same as that of their parents, so that Israel does not automatically grant citizenship to those born in its territory: “A child born in Israel to whom Section 4 of the Law of Return does not apply shall have the same status in Israel as his parents; if his parents do not have the same status, the child shall receive the status of his father or guardian unless the other parent objects in writing; if the other parent objects, the child shall receive the status of one of his parents, as the Minister shall determine.”
What Is Important to Know When Applying for a B/1 Work Visa for a Foreign Worker:
The process of obtaining a B/1 work visa begins with a formal application by the employer to the Permits Unit of the Population and Immigration Authority. As part of the application, the employer must prove the need to employ the foreign worker and attach appropriate supporting documents, such as a future employment contract, documents showing the worker’s expertise, or relevant training certificates.
Once the Permits Unit approves the application and issues an initial permit, the employer must apply to the Population Administration office at the Ministry of the Interior for the actual issuance of the work visa.
At this stage, the visa is stamped in the foreign worker’s passport, and it is valid only for the employer who applied and in the specific field of occupation approved in advance.
It is important to note that during the period of employment, it is strictly prohibited to transfer the foreign worker to another employer or to change his or her field of occupation without obtaining an additional appropriate permit.
In addition, there are financial costs imposed on the employer, including a one-time application fee and a special levy of 8% of the worker’s wages, paid to the assessing officer every month.
The law expressly prohibits deducting these amounts from the worker’s wages. In certain sectors, such as construction, there are special provisions that restrict the employment of foreign workers to licensed manpower contractors holding special permits.
When Applying for a B/1 Work Visa for a Foreign Worker, It Is Very Important to Have the Following Ready:
An application form for a permit to employ a foreign worker: This is the key document that sets the process in motion. The employer fills out the form with the Permits Unit, giving full details of the position, the nature of the employment, the worker’s details, and the reasons for choosing this particular worker.
A signed employment contract: The contract must include the salary, working hours, areas of responsibility, place of work, social benefits, and duration of employment. In the expert tracks, a high salary level in accordance with the requirements of the law must be included.
A professional description of the position: A document detailing the position being filled, including the required skills, the scope of the position, and the justification for recruiting a worker from abroad. Care must be taken to word it precisely, making clear what is unique about the position.
Proof of the worker’s expertise: This usually includes a résumé, educational certificates, professional certificates, and sometimes letters of recommendation or confirmation of experience. The purpose of these documents is to prove that the worker is specifically suited to the position.
An employer’s affidavit signed before a lawyer: A formal statement in which the employer confirms that he or she is aware of his or her obligations toward the foreign worker, undertakes to act in accordance with the law, and declares that the information submitted in the application is true.
Proof of payment of the fee: Without payment of the fee, the application is not examined. The fee is paid according to the length of employment and the type of visa, and care must be taken to attach an up-to-date receipt.
A valid passport: The worker must hold a passport valid for at least six months from the date of the application. It is important to make sure the passport is in good condition, not damaged, and not close to expiring.
A certificate of good conduct: A certificate from the country of citizenship or the country of last residence, signed by the appropriate authority; sometimes a notarized translation and an apostille are also required. The document confirms the absence of a recent criminal record.
Medical certificates: In accordance with the requirements of the Ministry of Health, general medical tests, usually including tests for tuberculosis and HIV, and blood tests. The documents must be from an authorized medical provider.
A copy of the employment contract: A document submitted to the consulate for verification, to make sure the worker knows the terms and that there are no discrepancies between what was submitted in Israel and what is presented in the foreign country.
A recent passport-size photo: A photo meeting the consulate’s requirements must be attached (light background, clearly visible facial features, standard size). Photos that do not meet the requirements may delay the application.
Fingerprints or a biometric identification form: In some countries, the worker must undergo biometric identification as part of the visa process. The requirement varies according to the guidelines of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Population Authority.
The Process of Obtaining a Work Visa for Israel in Brief:
1) The Israeli employer opens the process
The employer submits an application for a permit to employ a specific foreign worker, detailing the position, the worker’s skills and experience, and the proposed salary.
2) The Population Authority reviews the application
If the application meets the sector-specific and legal requirements, the employer is issued an employment permit in principle.
3) The worker applies at the Israeli consulate abroad
After the permit is received, the worker applies for a B/1 work visa, attaching a passport, a certificate of good conduct, medical certificates, the employment contract, and other documents as needed.
4) An entry visa to Israel is issued
If the application is approved, the worker receives a temporary entry visa that allows him or her to enter Israel to begin the employment.
5) On arrival in Israel, the final visa is issued
The worker appears at a Population Authority office, where the actual work visa is issued in accordance with the employer, field, and period of employment that were approved.
6) Work is permitted only under the terms of the visa
The worker may work only for the approved employer, in the approved field, and for the set period. Deviating from these terms may be considered a violation of the visa.
Work Visas for Expert Workers
Besides being a general visa for foreign workers in Israel, the B/1 work visa is in many cases intended for workers with unique expertise: foreign experts. These expert workers, whether or not they have an academic education, come to Israel to perform professional work that requires special knowledge, proven experience, or exceptional technological ability.
Because of their great importance to the Israeli economy, there are dedicated and detailed procedures for employing them, which distinguish them from ordinary foreign workers and impose specific requirements on employers.
One of the main tracks is called SEA (Short Employment Authorization), and it is intended for expert workers whose stay does not exceed 90 days a year. This track allows a particularly short process, usually taking up to about 10 working days.
The worker must be guaranteed a minimum wage (at least the national minimum wage), and the employer is required to provide the worker with medical insurance. In addition, in certain cases, mainly when the worker does not have an academic degree, the employer may be required to deposit a bank guarantee of about NIS 20,000, which will be returned after the worker leaves Israel.
Another track is called STEP. This track also allows expert workers to stay in Israel for up to 90 days, but the process of obtaining the permit may take six to eight weeks. In this track as well, the wage conditions are the same as in the previous track (at least the minimum wage), and there is the same requirement regarding medical insurance and depositing a financial guarantee in appropriate cases.
There are also dedicated tracks for expert workers who come to Israel for a longer period, usually a year. These expert workers, whether or not they have an academic education, are entitled to a minimum salary of twice the national average wage, currently about NIS 20,856 gross per month.
In addition, employers are subject to increased requirements regarding guarantees, ranging from NIS 20,000 to NIS 40,000, depending on the foreign worker’s professional status.
Note that expert workers in the high-tech sector benefit from a particularly fast, dedicated track. Under this track, Israeli high-tech companies registered with the Israel Innovation Authority, at least 75% of whose employees are engaged in research and development, can bring expert workers to Israel within as little as 10 working days.
Here too, the minimum wage conditions are twice the national average wage (NIS 20,856 gross). Moreover, the spouse of an expert worker in the high-tech sector is given the option of working in Israel without restriction to a particular field of occupation or employer, through a general B/1 visa, which allows maximum flexibility during their stay in Israel.
Workers in Non-Professional Sectors: Caregiving, Agriculture, Construction, and Hotels
The tracks in the “non-professional” sectors, as defined by the Ministry of the Interior, are intended to meet systemic needs of the local labor market in fields that have suffered for years from a structural shortage of Israeli workers.
Foreign workers in these sectors are almost always employed only through licensed corporations, subject to annual quotas set by government decisions and Population and Immigration Authority procedures.
In the caregiving sector, for example, the process is unique in that it is also available to private households, subject to the patient meeting eligibility conditions (age, functional dependence, receipt of a special services allowance, and so on).
Unlike other tracks, it allows an ongoing relationship of years between a single worker and a single patient, and sometimes even an extension beyond the usual maximum of 63 months, on humanitarian grounds.
Such extensions are considered by a dedicated committee at the Population Authority and must meet strict criteria (continuity of employment, a professional assessment, and preventing a sudden break in care).
In the construction sector, by contrast, the visa is usually granted to workers from China or Eastern Europe, through a supervised, time-limited process and only to employers holding a special permit. The sector is closely supervised to prevent underpayment, poor housing conditions, and exploitation.
Work Visas for Israel: Case Law Review:
As a rule, the prevailing policy in Israel is to reduce the number of foreign workers considerably. However, from time to time there is some flexibility when a need to employ foreign workers in certain fields does arise, as aptly stated:
“Government policy is to reduce the number of foreign workers in the country. Therefore, as argued, the allocation of permits to employ foreign workers must be carried out according to precise and orderly procedures that, on the one hand, ensure that the principle of equality is upheld and, on the other hand, protect the State’s interest in not allowing the employment of foreign workers beyond the maximum number it wishes to permit.”[8]
For example, to illustrate how important it is to comply with the conditions of a permit granted to employ a foreign worker, consider a case in which a man sought to employ dancers in Israel but was refused because of a previous breach of the permit conditions.
It should be emphasized that this was a dance troupe that had already been active for more than 16 years. The court held:
“However, one argument of the respondents tips the scales with respect to the petition. The respondents’ inquiry revealed that the petitioner did not comply with the conditions of the permits previously granted to him, in that one dancer whose permit to stay in the country had expired several years earlier remained living in Israel and continues to be employed in the petitioner’s troupe. In these circumstances, the respondents are right that the petitioner breached the trust placed in him and showed contempt for complying with the binding conditions imposed on him.”[9]
In the past, foreign workers were not entitled to health and social rights, only to a very small and incomplete basket. Today, after the Supreme Court ruled on the matter, the basket granted to foreign workers is much broader, as held:
“More specifically, I believe that in the present context we should address both the infringement of the right to health as derived from the right to human dignity and an independent infringement of the right to human dignity. The infringement of the right to health: the right to health, at least at its core, is bound up with the right to dignity, and it is also derived from the right to life and the protection of a person’s body.”[10]
Summary:
Employing a foreign worker is a very complex matter, as is the law on visas in Israel, including the B/1 visa, that is, the work visa for Israel. Therefore, it is very important, and almost always advisable, to use the services of a lawyer who specializes in Ministry of the Interior matters and knows the field, and equally not to forget the extent of the obligations imposed on the employer when employing foreign workers.
[1] Sections 9-10 of the Entry into Israel Law.
[2] Section 1B of the Foreign Workers Law.
[3] Section 1C of the Foreign Workers Law.
[4] Section 1E of the Foreign Workers Law.
[5] Chapter D3 of the Foreign Workers Law.
[6] HCJ 4542/02 Kav LaOved et al. v. Government of Israel et al., PD 61(1) 346.
[7] Section 1B(c) of the Foreign Workers Law.
[8]HCJ 3445/05 Sushimai 2004 Ltd. v. Ministry of Industry, Trade and Labor – Auxiliary Unit (published in Nevo), para. E.
[9] HCJ 9723/01 Levi v. Director of the Industry and Services Department for Foreign Worker Permits, PD 57(2) 87.
[10]HCJ 1105/06 Kav LaOved v. Minister of Welfare (published in Nevo), para. 2 of the opinion of Justice D. Barak-Erez.
